Using Discourses for Policy Evaluation: The Case of Marine Common Property Rights in Chile
- 23 March 2005
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Society & Natural Resources
- Vol. 18 (4) , 377-391
Abstract
In an attempt to combine marine conservation and economic development, the Chilean government introduced a policy that gives formal property rights over defined areas of seabed to artisanal fishers. This study used discourse analysis to understand the impacts and consequences of this policy. Story lines based on sustainability, livelihood maintenance, and historical right claims are mechanisms by which three different groups of fishers adopted postures toward the policy and each other. These act as a means of legitimizing claims when adapting to conditions generated by the policy and also vindicate poaching between syndicates, thereby jeopardizing the whole system. Results show the fishing groups studied adopt the policy for different reasons than those espoused by government during its development. Discourse analysis assists the understanding of actors’ policy responses and provides an insightful tool to investigate incentives and dominance of particular sets of ideas in a comanagement framework.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- The tyranny of the past: why local histories matter in the South African fisheriesOcean & Coastal Management, 2003
- Competing Visions for Marine Tenure and Co-Management: Genesis of a Marine Management Area System in ChileCoastal Management, 2002
- Recruitment of Homalaspis plana in intertidal habitats of central Chile and implications for the current use of Management and Marine Protected AreasMarine Ecology Progress Series, 2000
- New regulations in Chilean Fisheries and Aquaculture: ITQ’s and Territorial Users RightsOcean & Coastal Management, 1999
- Social theory and fisheries co-managementMarine Policy, 1998
- Farming and environmental discourses: A study of the depiction of environmental issues in a German farming newspaperJournal of Rural Studies, 1996
- Contesting Terrain in Zimbabwe's Eastern Highlands: Political Ecology, Ethnography, and Peasant Resource StrugglesEconomic Geography, 1993
- Non‐parametric multivariate analyses of changes in community structureAustralian Journal of Ecology, 1993
- Locality and custom: Non-aboriginal claims to customary usufructuary rights as a source of rural protestJournal of Rural Studies, 1990
- Positioning: The Discursive Production of SelvesJournal for the Theory of Social Behaviour, 1990