Reasoning versus knowledge retention and ascertainment throughout a problem‐based learning curriculum
- 20 August 2009
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Medical Education
- Vol. 43 (9) , 854-865
Abstract
Context Since 2000, problem‐based learning (PBL) seminars have been introduced into the curriculum of medical studies at the University of Liège. We aimed to carry out a cross‐sectional investigation of the maturational increase in biomedical reasoning capacity in comparison with factual knowledge retention throughout the curriculum. Methods We administered a factual knowledge test (i.e. a true/false test with ascertainment degree) and a biomedical reasoning test (i.e. an adapted script concordance test [SCT]) to 104 students (Years 3–6) and a reference panel. The selected topic was endocrinology. Results On the SCT, the students obtained higher scores in Years 5 and 6 than in Years 3 and 4. In Year 3, the scores obtained on SCT questions in a new context indicated transfer of reasoning skills. On the true/false test, the scores of Year 3 students were significantly higher than those of students in the other three year groups. A positive correlation between SCT scores and true/false test scores was observed only for students in Years 3 and 4. In each group, the ascertainment degree scores were higher for correct than for incorrect responses and the difference was calculated as an index of self‐estimation of core knowledge. This index was found to be positively correlated to SCT scores in the four year groups studied. Conclusions Biomedical reasoning skills are evidenced early in a curriculum involving PBL and further increase during training. This is accompanied by a decrease in factual knowledge retention. The self‐estimation of core knowledge appears to be related to reasoning capacity, which suggests there is a link between the two processes.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Development of clinical reasoning from the basic sciences to the clerkships: a longitudinal assessment of medical students' needs and self‐perception after a transitional learning unitMedical Education, 2003
- Issues in cognitive psychologyAcademic Medicine, 1996
- Elaborated knowledgeAcademic Medicine, 1994
- What goes around comes around: Return of the hypothetico-deductive strategyTeaching and Learning in Medicine, 1994
- On acquiring expertise in medicineEducational Psychology Review, 1993
- The psychological basis of problem-based learningAcademic Medicine, 1992
- On the Role of Biomedical Knowledge in Clinical Reasoning by Experts, Intermediates and NovicesCognitive Science, 1992
- A cognitive perspective on medical expertiseAcademic Medicine, 1990
- Knowledge Based Solution Strategies in Medical ReasoningCognitive Science, 1986
- Problem‐based learning: rationale and descriptionMedical Education, 1983