‘Scienciness’ and the allure of second-hand strategy in talent identification and development
- 1 July 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in International Journal of Sport Policy and Politics
- Vol. 5 (2) , 183-191
Abstract
In searching for the next edge or the magic ingredient, policymakers in sport are increasingly drawn to seemingly uncritical copying from other systems. Some of the constructs seem attractive, holding an apparent validity that promotes their adoption but, on closer scrutiny, can appear to be based more on rhetoric than evidence. In this article we propose the new term of ‘Scienciness’ to describe this apparent but erroneous validity, offering an exemplar of its harmful impact through the import into the United Kingdom of features from apparently successful systems in talent development, namely, the former Eastern Bloc and Australia. This article identifies some characteristics of Scienciness constructs, together with some procedural and systemic recommendations for the avoidance of its worse excesses.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Long-Term Athlete Development model: Physiological evidence and applicationJournal of Sports Sciences, 2011
- Conclusion2008
- Comparative elite sport development2008
- Policy transfer, lesson drawing and perspectives on elite sport development systemsInternational Journal of Sport Management and Marketing, 2007
- Early Specialization in Youth Sport: a requirement for adult expertise?High Ability Studies, 2003
- A Theoretical and Empirical Analysis of a 'State of the Art' Talent Identification ModelHigh Ability Studies, 2002
- Social Science and the Evidence-based Policy MovementSocial Policy and Society, 2002
- Risks and Benefits of Youth Sport Specialization: Perspectives and RecommendationsPediatric Exercise Science, 2000
- The making of the UK Sports InstituteManaging Leisure, 1999
- Who Learns What from Whom: A Review of the Policy Transfer LiteraturePolitical Studies, 1996