Reluctant Referrals: The Effectiveness of Legal Coercion in Outpatient Treatment for Problem Drinkers
Authors:
- Roger G. DunhamRDRoger G. Dunham
- Armand L. MaussAMArmand L. Mauss
- 1 January 1982
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Drug Issues
- Vol. 12 (1) , 5-20
Abstract
An annoying paradox which has been facing policy-makers and practitioners alike in their efforts to deal with public problem drinkers is that of recognizing the condition of alcohol-related offenders as both a misdemeanor and a disease. This paradox is discussed in terms of a legal model and a therapeutic model for responding to alcohol-related problems. A multivariate covariance model is used to compare the effectiveness of treatment for problem drinkers coerced into treatment by the courts and problem drinkers voluntarily initiating treatment, while statistically controlling for pre-treatment group differences. With regards to effectiveness, and the role played by an element of coercion in effectiveness, type of referral did have an important independent impact upon treatment outcome. An element of coercion involved in that referral did not subvert the goals of the therapeutic model; indeed, it rendered successful treatment outcome considerably more likely than with strictly voluntary self-referral. Finally, coercion proved somewhat more effective where the penalties for non-compliance were the more certain, not necessarily the more severe.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- Evaluation of Treatment ProgramsEvaluation Quarterly, 1979
- Padding the Revolving Door: An Initial Assessment of the Uniform Alcoholism and Intoxication Treatment Act in PracticeSocial Problems, 1978
- The referral problem in the field of alcohol abuseJournal of Community Psychology, 1976
- Referral to alcoholism programs in industry. Coercion, confrontation and choice.Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1976
- Use of coercion in the outpatient treatment of alcoholism.Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1976
- A mandatory treatment program for skid row alcoholics; its implication for the Uniform Alcoholism and Intoxication Treatment Act.Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1975
- Employed Alcoholics Treated Voluntarily and Under Constructive CoercionQuarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1974
- The Revolving-Door AlcoholicArchives of General Psychiatry, 1973
- Enforced Clinic Treatment of Paroled Criminal Alcoholics; a Pilot EvaluationQuarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1968
- A Court Clinic for Alcoholics. A Description and Evaluation of the Stoughton ClinicQuarterly Journal of Studies on Alcohol, 1951