A coda: oversimplification, implicit assumptions, and measurement error
Author:
- M. S GilthorpeMGM. S Gilthorpe
Open Access
- 1 December 2004
- journal article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Journal of Epidemiology
- Vol. 33 (6) , 1402-1403
Abstract
This debate demonstrates the range of approaches, and their associated limitations, used to examine this deceptively complex issue. An understanding of the range of relationships of errors with each other and with the unobserved measures is crucial. We concur with all contributors that our pieces are an oversimplification, making various implicit assumptions that were omitted in the interests of simplicity and brevity; it is valuable to receive further comments and insights from other correspondents. We summarize what we feel are the main conclusions to draw from this debate. The debate on underlying assumptions is probably more philosophical than statistical. There are differences in the adopted definitions of 'true' outcome and associated assessment errors. For instance, Ian White1 begins with the assumption that over-/under-reporting is present and therefore assessment errors are correlated with unobserved values for self-report whilst uncorrelated for measurement. Consequently, using Oldham's method to test for unequal variances is only valid if error variances of self-report and measurement are equal, which one cannot readily assess. In contrast, we made no assumptions about the correlation between assessment errors and unobserved values, as this is what we sought to test, though we assumed equal error variances. Oldham's method is then valid. The paradox of a method being valid/ invalid with different assumptions for the same problem further reflects the complexity of this issue!Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pharmacogenetics: potential for individualized drug therapy through geneticsTrends in Genetics, 2003
- Genome scans and candidate gene approaches in the study of common diseases and variable drug responsesTrends in Genetics, 2003
- Locating gene–environment interaction: at the intersections of genetics and public healthSocial Science & Medicine, 2003
- Fulfilling the promise: drug discovery in the post-genomic eraDrug Discovery Today, 2003
- Meta-analysis of genetic association studies supports a contribution of common variants to susceptibility to common diseaseNature Genetics, 2003
- Association between presence of HLA-B*5701, HLA-DR7 , and HLA-DQ3 and hypersensitivity to HIV-1 reverse-transcriptase inhibitor abacavirThe Lancet, 2002
- Association study designs for complex diseasesNature Reviews Genetics, 2001
- How many diseases does it take to map a gene with SNPs?Nature Genetics, 2000
- Single nucleotide polymorphisms and the future of genetic epidemiologyClinical Genetics, 2000
- Searching for genetic determinants in the new millenniumNature, 2000