Roles and Power within Federal Problem Solving Courtroom Workgroups
- 3 September 2012
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Law & Policy
- Vol. 34 (4) , 402-427
Abstract
Problem solving (PS) courts (e.g., drug, family, gang, prostitution, reentry) are becoming more commonplace. Today, PS courts exist or are planned in nearly all of the ninety‐four U.S. federal districts. These courts focus on integrating therapeutic jurisprudence into the courtroom environment while emphasizing group decision‐making processes among courtroom workgroup members. In this legal setting, courtroom workgroup teams, regularly consisting of judges, prosecutors, defense attorneys, probation officers (POs), and treatment providers engage a collective, case management approach to decision making with shared power among team members. However, despite the court's therapeutic and collaborative design, we find that POs wield powerful influence in decision making. Informed by sixteen months of qualitative fieldwork, including semistructured interviews, observation of courtroom workgroup meetings, and court observations in five federal PS courts in three federal districts, we find that POs exert undetected informational, technical, and relational power within the PS courtroom workgroup. This role and its accompanying power transforms POs into key decision makers, regardless of PS court type, workgroup dynamics, and decision‐making style. The POs' role makes them critical contributors to the outcomes in federal PS courts with important implications for punishment decisions in the federal justice system. With an increasing number of PS courts currently in the planning stages at the federal level, our study has implications for the structure and decision outcomes in these growing courtroom workgroups.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contingency management for treatment of substance use disorders: a meta‐analysisAddiction, 2006
- Problem‐Solving Courts: A Brief PrimerLaw & Policy, 2001
- Probationer violations and officer responseJournal of Criminal Justice, 1992
- Boundary spanners: A key component for the effective interactions of the justice and mental health systems.Law and Human Behavior, 1992
- Maintaining the myth of individualized justice: Probation presentence reportsJustice Quarterly, 1988
- Power as an experiential conceptScandinavian Journal of Management, 1988
- Ceremonial Justice: Crime and Punishment in a Loosely Coupled SystemSocial Forces, 1979
- The Bases and Use of Power in Organizational Decision Making: The Case of a UniversityAdministrative Science Quarterly, 1974
- Client Control and Medical PracticeAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1960
- Community Within a Community: The ProfessionsAmerican Sociological Review, 1957