Breaking the Single Voice: Perceived AI Plurality as an Autonomy-Supportive Architecture for Ethical Marketplace Decisions
Open Access
- 10 August 2026
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Macromarketing
Abstract
Artificial intelligence (AI) increasingly structures how consumers encounter, evaluate, and select marketplace options, raising fundamental questions about autonomy, empowerment, and welfare-enhancing choice environments. While prior work has focused on what algorithms recommend, less is known about how recommendation system architecture shapes the experience of choice. Across three experiments, this research examines the societal and psychological implications of perceived algorithmic plurality, defined as consumers’ perception that recommendation authority is distributed across multiple distinct AI agents, each guided by distinct evaluative criteria. Results show that structuring ethical recommendations through a plural AI architecture enhances consumers’ self–brand connection. Study 2 demonstrates that plural recommendations increase perceived autonomy, which strengthens self–brand connection and purchase intentions. Study 3 shows these effects are strongest among low-knowledge consumers, suggesting plurality can function as an equity-enhancing design feature. By shifting attention from algorithmic outputs to the socio-technical structure of AI nudges, this research advances understanding of consumer emancipation in digital marketplaces.Keywords
Funding Information
- XLRI-Xavier School of Management grant (XLRG2309)
- Toronto Metropolitan University (2026-090)
This publication has 68 references indexed in Scilit:
- The FOMO Effect: How AI Recommendations Drive Consumer Dependence and Weaken Brand‐Self ConnectionsJournal of Consumer Behaviour, 2026
- AI nudging and decision quality: Evidence from randomized experiments in online recommendation settingDecision Support Systems, 2025
- From Price to Quantity: Redefining How Consumers Pay the Ethical PremiumJournal of Business Ethics, 2025
- Flipping the Script: Harnessing Consumer Knowledge, Message Order and Refutation for Effective Two‐Sided Green AdvertisingPsychology & Marketing, 2025
- True Consumer Autonomy: A Formalization and ImplicationsJournal of Business Ethics, 2022
- Leveraging Artificial Intelligence in Marketing for Social Good—An Ethical PerspectiveJournal of Business Ethics, 2021
- When do you trust AI? The effect of number presentation detail on consumer trust and acceptance of AI recommendationsPsychology & Marketing, 2021
- Consumer Choice and Autonomy in the Age of Artificial Intelligence and Big DataCustomer Needs and Solutions, 2017
- Digital NudgingBusiness & Information Systems Engineering, 2016
- Beyond nudges: Tools of a choice architectureMarketing Letters, 2012