The Unbearable Limitations of Journalism
- 22 January 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in International Communication Gazette
- Vol. 72 (1) , 21-33
Abstract
Though the impossibility of a mimetic and purely objective representation of reality is commonly accepted, it is striking that journalism's claim to truth and authenticity is still so vivid in journalism and in public discourse. Its supposed ability to to mirror reality by verifying true facts remains the basic assumption underlying press critique, as becomes clear in for example the books of Nick Davies and Joris Luyendijk who both criticize journalism for its inability to represent social reality accurately. This article contends that to go beyond the unbearable limitations of journalism and understand how it works, we should not approach journalism as a descriptive discourse but on the contrary as a performative discourse designed to persuade readers that what it describes is real. By successfully doing so, journalism transforms an interpretation into truth — into a reality the public can act upon. It is furthermore argued that journalism does not derive its performative power from its contents (the facts), but merely from its forms and style. News consumers tend to believe the contents that come with professional routines and conventions, justifying and masking the subjective interpretation and news selection of the individual journalist. If we acknowledge that journalism is a performative discourse it is impossible to be transparent about its limitations and its inability to discover the truth and introduce structural ambiguity in news writing as is suggested by press critics.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Working at the End of the Assembly Line: A Conversation with Joris Luyendijk about the Impossibility of Doing Western-style Journalism in Arab CountriesThe International Journal of Press/Politics, 2008
- On “Having Been There”: “Eyewitnessing” as a Journalistic Key WordCritical Studies in Media Communication, 2007
- Scowling at their NotebooksJournalism, 2003
- The objectivity norm in American journalism*Journalism, 2001
- The birth of news discourse: changes in news language in British newspapers, 1880-1930Media, Culture & Society, 2000
- From behind the Walls: Boundary Work by News Organizations in Their Coverage of Princess Diana's DeathJournal of Communication Inquiry, 1999
- Journalism as an Anglo-American InventionEuropean Journal of Communication, 1996
- Journalists as interpretive communitiesCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1993
- On journalistic authority: The Janet Cooke scandalCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1986
- “New Journalism, Metaphor and Culture”The Journal of Popular Culture, 1982