Psychological interventions for antisocial personality disorder
- 16 June 2010
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
- No. 6,p. CD007668
Abstract
Background Antisocial personality disorder (AsPD) is associated with a wide range of disturbance including persistent rule‐breaking, criminality, substance use, unemployment, homelessness and relationship difficulties. Objectives To evaluate the potential beneficial and adverse effects of psychological interventions for people with AsPD. Search methods Our search included CENTRAL Register of Controlled Trials, MEDLINE, EMBASE, CINAHL, PsycINFO, ASSIA, BIOSIS and COPAC. Selection criteria Prospective, controlled trials in which participants with AsPD were randomly allocated to a psychological intervention and a control condition (either treatment as usual, waiting list or no treatment). Data collection and analysis Three authors independently selected studies. Two authors independently extracted data. We calculated mean differences, with odds ratios for dichotomous data. Main results Eleven studies involving 471 participants with AsPD met the inclusion criteria, although data were available from only five studies involving 276 participants with AsPD. Only two studies focused solely on an AsPD sample. Eleven different psychological interventions were examined. Only two studies reported on reconviction, and only one on aggression. Compared to the control condition, cognitive behaviour therapy (CBT) plus standard maintenance was superior for outpatients with cocaine dependence in one study, but CBT plus treatment as usual was not superior for male outpatients with recent verbal/physical violence in another. Contingency management plus standard maintenance was superior for drug misuse for outpatients with cocaine dependence in one study but not in another, possibly because of differences in the behavioural intervention. However, contingency management was superior in social functioning and counselling session attendance in the latter. A multi‐component intervention utilising motivational interviewing principles, the ‘Driving Whilst Intoxicated program’, plus incarceration was superior to incarceration alone for imprisoned drink‐driving offenders. Authors' conclusions Results suggest that there is insufficient trial evidence to justify using any psychological intervention for adults with AsPD. Disappointingly few of the included studies addressed the primary outcomes defined in this review (aggression, reconviction, global functioning, social functioning, adverse effects). Three interventions (contingency management with standard maintenance; CBT with standard maintenance; 'Driving Whilst Intoxicated program' with incarceration) appeared effective, compared to the control condition, in terms of improvement in at least one outcome in at least one study. Each of these interventions had been originally developed for people with substance misuse problems. Significant improvements were mainly confined to outcomes related to substance misuse. No study reported significant change in any specific antisocial behaviour. Further research is urgently needed for this prevalent and costly condition.Keywords
This publication has 102 references indexed in Scilit:
- Do personality problems improve during psychodynamic supportive–expressive psychotherapy? Secondary outcome results from a randomized controlled trial for psychiatric outpatients with personality disorders.Psychotherapy, 2009
- Antisocial personality disorder and psychopathy in women: A literature review on the reliability and validity of assessment instrumentsInternational Journal of Law and Psychiatry, 2009
- Cognitive behaviour therapy for violent men with antisocial personality disorder in the community: an exploratory randomized controlled trialPsychological Medicine, 2008
- The interactive effects of antisocial personality disorder and court-mandated status on substance abuse treatment dropoutJournal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 2008
- Antidepressant medicationsv.cognitive therapy in people with depression with or without personality disorderThe British Journal of Psychiatry, 2008
- Animal-assisted therapy with farm animals for persons with psychiatric disorders: effects on self-efficacy, coping ability and quality of life, a randomized controlled trialClinical Practice & Epidemiology in Mental Health, 2008
- A behavioral treatment for opioid-dependent patients with antisocial personalityJournal of Substance Abuse Treatment, 2008
- Do Comorbid Personality Disorders Moderate Panic-Focused Psychotherapy?The Journal of Clinical Psychiatry, 2007
- Adapting judicial supervision to the risk level of drug offenders: Discharge and 6-month outcomes from a prospective matching studyDrug and Alcohol Dependence, 2007
- The Effect of a Case Management Intervention on Drug Treatment Entry Among Treatment-Seeking Injection Drug Users With and Without Comorbid Antisocial Personality DisorderJournal of Urban Health, 2007