Potential Pitfalls of Reporting and Bias in Observational Studies With Propensity Score Analysis Assessing a Surgical Procedure
Authors:
- Guillaume LonjonGLGuillaume Lonjon
- Raphael PorcherRPRaphael Porcher
- Patrick ErginaPEPatrick Ergina
- Mathilde FouetMFMathilde Fouet
- Isabelle BoutronIBIsabelle Boutron
- 1 May 2017
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Annals of Surgery
- Vol. 265 (5) , 901-909
Abstract
To describe the evolution of the use and reporting of propensity score (PS) analysis in observational studies assessing a surgical procedure. Assessing surgery in randomized controlled trials raises several challenges. Observational studies with PS analysis are a robust alternative for comparative effectiveness research. In this methodological systematic review, we identified all PubMed reports of observational studies with PS analysis that evaluated a surgical procedure and described the evolution of their use over time. Then, we selected a sample of articles published from August 2013 to July 2014 and systematically appraised the quality of reporting and potential bias of the PS analysis used. We selected 652 reports of observational studies with PS analysis. The publications increased over time, from 1 report in 1987 to 198 in 2013. Among the 129 reports assessed, 20% (n = 24) did not detail the covariates included in the PS and 77% (n = 100) did not report a justification for including these covariates in the PS. The rate of missing data for potential covariates was reported in 9% of articles. When a crossover by conversion was possible, only 14% of reports (n = 12) mentioned this issue. For matched analysis, 10% of articles reported all 4 key elements that allow for reproducibility of a PS-matched analysis (matching ratio, method to choose the nearest neighbors, replacement and method for statistical analysis). Observational studies with PS analysis in surgery are increasing in frequency, but specific methodological issues and weaknesses in reporting exist.Keywords
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Limits to clinical trials in surgical areasClinics, 2011
- Challenges in evaluating surgical innovationThe Lancet, 2009
- Comparative Effectiveness Research: A Report From the Institute of MedicineAnnals of Internal Medicine, 2009
- Analysis of Observational Studies in the Presence of Treatment Selection BiasJAMA, 2007
- External validity of randomised controlled trials: “To whom do the results of this trial apply?”The Lancet, 2005
- Comparison of Logistic Regression versus Propensity Score When the Number of Events Is Low and There Are Multiple ConfoundersAmerican Journal of Epidemiology, 2003
- Epidemiologic analyses of causation: the unlearned scientific lessons of randomized trialsJournal of Clinical Epidemiology, 1989
- The central role of the propensity score in observational studies for causal effectsBiometrika, 1983
- Randomized versus historical controls for clinical trialsThe American Journal of Medicine, 1982
- Randomized Clinical TrialsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1976