The Depiction of Native Americans in Recent (1991–2004) Secondary American History Textbooks: How Far Have We Come?
Author:
- Tony R. SanchezTSTony R. Sanchez
- 16 November 2007
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Equity & Excellence in Education
- Vol. 40 (4) , 311-320
Abstract
This study examined 15 secondary American history textbooks to evaluate their accuracy in depicting Native Americans as a follow-up to studies by Costo and Henry (1970) Costo, R. and Henry, J. , eds. 1970. Textbooks and the American Indian, The Indian Historian Press. [Google Scholar] and Loewen (1995) Loewen, J. 1995. Lies my teacher told me: Everything your American history textbook got wrong, New York: The New York Press. [Google Scholar] . The criteria embodied an authenticity guideline based upon the Five Great Values with a rating scale between 1 (lowest) and 5 (highest). The results indicate that only three of the textbooks rated above average. Though generally the textbooks have improved in quantity of cultural information, better treatments must be pursued that reflect more accurate and comprehensive accounts. The challenge lies in assisting educators' acquisition of knowledge and familiarity with Native cultures as they are depicted in textbooks, an endeavor that will further assist these teachers in adopting and utilizing proper textbooks.Keywords
This publication has 6 references indexed in Scilit:
- Finding Empowerment through Writing and Reading, or Why Am I Doing This?: An Unpopular Writer's Comments about the State of American Indian Literary CriticismThe American Indian Quarterly, 2004
- “Dangerous Indians”Urban Education, 2001
- "Thinking Like an Indian": Exploring American Indian Views of American HistoryReviews in American History, 2001
- Authoritative Texts, Collaborative Ethnography, and Native American StudiesThe American Indian Quarterly, 2000
- The Social Studies Teacher's LamentUrban Education, 1997
- Multiculturalism: Practical Considerations for Curricular ChangeThe Clearing House: A Journal of Educational Strategies, Issues and Ideas, 1996