Liver allocation: urgency of need or prospect of success? Ethical considerations
Authors:
- 1 July 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Clinical Transplantation
- Vol. 27 (s25) , 34-39
Abstract
In German legislation and in Eurotransplant's practice of liver allocation, urgency of need is considered as the primary distribution criterion. However, at a certain stage, the “sickest‐first” principle is regarded as counterproductive as the performance status of these patients receiving an organ is on average critical and mortality and morbidity after liver transplantation increase. Within the medical transplant community, the criterion of prospect for success is highly accepted. As clinicians having a certain scope in decision‐making as “gatekeepers” in regard to which patient gets on the waiting list and at which stage a patient is defined as “not transplantable” and as transplantation centers aspire good success rates, the goal of high prospect for success might become more weighty than intended by legislation and professional guidelines. From an ethical point of view, it is submitted a so‐called mediatory approach in between the two extremes “sickest‐first” and “fittest‐first.” Beyond that, it is argued for further development of a prognostic score for post‐operative outcome after liver transplantation – as long as questions of social justice are borne in mind – to support “objective” decision‐making.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- http://www.D-MELD.com, the Italian survival calculator to optimize donor to recipient matching and to identify the unsustainable matches in liver transplantationTransplant International, 2012
- Liver transplantation in the high MELD era: a fair chance for everyone?Langenbeck's Archives of Surgery, 2011
- Aktuelle Entwicklungen der Lebertransplantation in Deutschland: MELD-basierte Organallokation und „incentives” für TransplantationszentrenZeitschrift für Gastroenterologie, 2011
- Multicentric evaluation of model for end-stage liver disease-based allocation and survival after liver transplantation in Germany - limitations of the ‘sickest first’-conceptTransplant International, 2010
- D-MELD, a Simple Predictor of Post Liver Transplant Mortality for Optimization of Donor/Recipient MatchingAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2009
- Evaluation of SOFA-based models for predicting mortality in the ICU: A systematic reviewCritical Care, 2008
- Survival Outcomes Following Liver Transplantation (SOFT) Score: A Novel Method to Predict Patient Survival Following Liver TransplantationAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2008
- The Survival Impact of Liver Transplantation in the MELD Era, and the Future for Organ Allocation and DistributionAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2005
- The Transplant Evaluation Rating ScalelPsychosomatics, 1993
- The Survival LotteryPhilosophy, 1975