Initiating decision‐making in neurology consultations: ‘recommending’ versus ‘option‐listing’ and the implications for medical authority
Authors:
- 2 April 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Sociology of Health & Illness
- Vol. 35 (6) , 873-890
Abstract
This article compares two practices for initiating treatment decision‐making, evident in audio‐recorded consultations between a neurologist and 13 patients in two hospital clinics in the UK. We call these ‘recommending’ and ‘option‐listing’. The former entails making a proposal to do something; the latter entails the construction of a list of options. Using conversation analysis (CA), we illustrate each, showing that the distinction between these two practices matters to participants. Our analysis centres on two distinctions between the practices: epistemic differences and differences in the slots each creates for the patient’s response. Considering the implications of our findings for understanding medical authority, we argue that option‐listing – relative to recommending – is a practice whereby clinicians work to relinquish a little of their authority. This article contributes, then, to a growing body of CA work that offers a more nuanced, tempered account of medical authority than is typically portrayed in the sociological literature. We argue that future CA studies should map out the range of ways – in addition to recommending – in which treatment decision‐making is initiated by clinicians. This will allow for further evidence‐based contributions to debates on the related concepts of patient participation, choice, shared decision‐making and medical authority.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- How surgeons design treatment recommendations in orthopaedic surgerySocial Science & Medicine, 2011
- Small talk, high stakes: Interactional disattentiveness in the context of prosocial doctor-patient interactionLanguage in Society, 2008
- ‘It's something for you both to think about’: choice and decision making in nuchal translucency screening for Down's syndromeSociology of Health & Illness, 2008
- Distributed decision making: the anatomy of decisions‐in‐actionSociology of Health & Illness, 2008
- Chapter 5. Revisiting authority in physician-patient interaction2005
- Patient "Demand" for Medical Interventions: Exerting Pressure for an Offerin a Primary Care Clinic VisitResearch on Language and Social Interaction, 2005
- Non-antibiotic treatment recommendations: delivery formats and implications for parent resistanceSocial Science & Medicine, 2005
- Breaking the sequential mold: Answering ‘more than the question’ during comprehensive history takingText & Talk, 2001
- Doctor–patient communication about drugs: the evidence for shared decision makingSocial Science & Medicine, 2000
- Interaction and Asymmetry in Clinical DiscourseAmerican Journal of Sociology, 1991