Defining Outcomes in Facial Gender-Affirming Surgery: A Systematic Review to Inform Core Outcome Set Development
Authors:
- Meghan N. MillerMeghan N. Miller
- Derrick LinDLDerrick Lin
- Samantha RabinovichSRSamantha Rabinovich
- Graysen AirthGAGraysen Airth
- Sabrina Rainsbury-SilvaSRSabrina Rainsbury-Silva
- Rebecca CanfieldRCRebecca Canfield
- Sarah FadichSFSarah Fadich
- Kaavian ShariatiKSKaavian Shariati
- James P. BradleyJBJames P. Bradley
- Justine C. LeeJLJustine C. Lee
Preprint
- 17 December 2025
- preprint
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Abstract
Facial gender-affirming surgery (FGAS) is a transformative step for transgender individuals in their gender care journey. Even so, the way outcomes are measured and reported is highly inconsistent and unstudied. This limits the ability to compare studies or develop clear, patient-centered benchmarks for success. We systematically assess how current research defines FGAS outcomes and lay the groundwork for a unified core outcome set (COS). A systematic review was conducted following PRISMA 2020 guidelines. PubMed was searched through March 15, 2025, we identified 334 studies, and four reviewers independently screened studies. After screening, 232 studies met inclusion criteria, encompassing 30,937 patients. Data were extracted on study characteristics, surgical procedures, outcome domains, measurement tools, and follow-up duration. Descriptive statistics and chi-square analyses were used to evaluate reporting trends. Most studies emphasized aesthetic outcomes (61.6%) and complications (60.0%), fewer addressed psychosocial well-being (45.7%), quality of life (21.6%), or reoperation rates (20.7%). Only 26 of the 232 studies used validated outcome instruments, such as FACE-Q or PROMIS (p < 0.001). Among studies that reported satisfaction, only 41.2% provided numerical or stratified scores. Outcome reporting in FGAS research is fragmented and dominated by subjective or unvalidated assessments. A standardized COS is needed to unify research practices, facilitate meaningful comparisons, and ensure that outcomes align with patient-defined measures of surgical success.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Type I+ Forehead in Facial Feminization SurgeryAesthetic Plastic Surgery, 2024
- Ethnic Variation in Lower Face Anthropometry on Facial Computed Tomography Scans for Patients Seeking Facial Feminization SurgeryJournal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery, 2024
- Preoperative Radiology and Virtual Surgical PlanningOral and Maxillofacial Surgery Clinics of North America, 2024
- The GenderCOS project: study protocol for the development of two international Core Outcome Sets for genital gender affirming surgeryInternational Journal of Transgender Health, 2023
- Ethical Issues Surrounding Facial Feminization Surgery: Five Major ConsiderationsAesthetic Surgery Journal, 2023
- An enhanced recovery after surgery protocol for facial feminization surgery reduces perioperative opioid usage, pain, and hospital stayJournal of Plastic, Reconstructive & Aesthetic Surgery, 2023
- Facial Feminization Surgery under Insurance: The University of California Los Angeles ExperiencePlastic and Reconstructive Surgery - Global Open, 2021
- Simplifying Facial Feminization Surgery Using Virtual Modeling on the Female SkullPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery - Global Open, 2020
- Facial Feminization SurgeryPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 2015
- Feminization of the Forehead: Contour Changing to Improve Female AestheticsPlastic and Reconstructive Surgery, 1987