Thermal Energy Storage Myths

Author:

Abstract
Using thermal energy storage has shifted gigawatts of power off daytime peaks in a cost-effective manner. However, thermal energy storage (TES) market penetration is small in comparison to its potential. Why? In TES' infancy (early 1980s), a small number of manufacturers carefully researched the technology and installed equipment. In the technology's adolescent years (late 1980s and early 1990s), dozens of manufacturers, chasing the new demand-side management rebate incentives, jumped into the marketplace. These difficult adolescent years resulted in tarnished reputations and the spread of misinformation about the technology. This article attempts to set the record straight on the myths and reality of this technology by demonstrating how TES is well-positioned to help the move towards more energy-efficient and environment-friendly air-conditioning systems. The obvious reason for installing TES is to reduce energy costs. Although deregulation of the electric industry has created localized anomalies in energy costs, the basic reality of supply and demand is that on-peak power is more expensive than off-peak power.1 One consistently proven aspect of TES is that it saves energy costs, which has more significance now that ANSI/ASHRAE/IESNA Standard 90.1, Energy Standard for Buildings Except Low-Rise Residential Buildings, and the LEED rating system are based on energy cost savings. Several TES projects that have won ASHRAE's Technology Award2,3,4 detail the cost-saving aspect. However, less emphasis has been given to the reductions of equipment size and infrastructure that normally occurs. The basic TES cooling systems that I base most of my analysis on are: Chiller-based systems. Throughout the adolescent years of TES, a variety of systems, including site-built liquid overfeed refrigeration systems, ice-harvesting equipment and others, were used successfully in other applications. However, 99 percent of commercial air-conditioning TES systems installed use a standard chiller to produce the cooling. Chillers are familiar, reliable, capacity rated, and competitively priced. They cool water or a glycol-water solution. Ice-based storage. For projects where space is not as much of a consideration, chilled water storage is becoming widely used.5 However, since so much HVAC work involves retrofits where space is a concern, ice is the likely choice. Closed system. Large district cooling systems use either water and/or ice as the storage media and the heat transfer fluid. These “open” systems create added hydraulic complications that need to be carefully addressed. However, most TES systems now separate the storage media from the heat transfer fluid, so the systems are the same hydraulically as most chiller systems.