Is the integrated/non-integrated distinction for embryo models really obsolete?
- 3 September 2025
- journal article
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 52 (9) , 608-611
Abstract
Stem cell-based embryo models (SCBEMs) offer new ways for studying early human development while circumventing ethical challenges associated with natural embryos. Traditionally, SCBEMs are categorised as ‘integrated’ or ‘non-integrated’, reflecting their capacity for coordinated development and potential to acquire morally relevant properties. However, the Code of Practice challenges this distinction, arguing that non-integrated SCBEMs can reach stages of significant developmental complexity, making the classification obsolete. This paper critiques the abandonment of the integrated/non-integrated framework. I argue that the distinction is tied, rightfully so, to developmental potential rather than structural complexity. For the ethical oversight of embryo models, the potential to develop morally relevant properties and thus the integrated/non-integrated distinction remains relevant.Keywords
Funding Information
- ZonMw (10250022120003)
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Language and labels from the lab: Definitions in the stem cell-based embryo model debateStem Cell Reports, 2025
- An ethical framework for human embryology with embryo modelsCell, 2023
- Human stem cell-derived embryo models: Toward ethically appropriate regulations and policiesCell Stem Cell, 2023
- Post-gastrulation synthetic embryos generated ex utero from mouse naive ESCsCell, 2022
- Human embryo research, stem cell-derived embryo models and in vitro gametogenesis: Considerations leading to the revised ISSCR guidelinesStem Cell Reports, 2021
- ISSCR Guidelines for Stem Cell Research and Clinical Translation: The 2021 updateStem Cell Reports, 2021
- Opportunities and challenges with stem cell-based embryo modelsStem Cell Reports, 2021
- The ethics of human-embryoids model: a call for consistencyJournal of Molecular Medicine, 2021
- Modelling human embryogenesis: embryo-like structures spark ethical and policy debateHuman Reproduction Update, 2020
- Embryonic Stem Cells in Development and Regenerative Medicine2018