A logical critique of the expert position in design research: beyond expert justification of design methods and towards empirical validation
Open Access
- 18 May 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Design Science
- Vol. 2
Abstract
This paper gives a general and logical analysis of theexpert positionin design research by which methods for innovative design can be derived from expert design practices. It first gives a framework for characterising accounts of design by the way in which they define and relategeneral,descriptiveandprescribedtypes of design practices. Second, it analyses with this framework the expert position’s conservatism of prescribing existing expert design practices to non-expert designers. Third, it argues that the expert status of expert designers does not provide sufficient justification for prescribing expert design practices to non-expert designers; it is shown that this justification needs support by empirical testing. Fourth, it discusses validation of design methods for presenting an approach to this testing. One consequence of the need to empirically test the expert position is that its prescription has to be formulated in more detail. Another consequence is that it undermines the expert position since expert design practices are not anymore certain sources for deriving design methods with. Yet it also opens the expert position to other sources for developing design methods for innovation, such as the practices of contemporary designers and the insights of design researchers.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Design Theories, Models and Their Testing: On the Scientific Status of Design Research2014
- Transferring Design Methods into Practice2011
- Introduction2011
- The Future of Design Methodology2011
- My method is better!Research in Engineering Design, 2010
- DRM, a Design Research Methodology2009
- Engineering Design2007
- Validation of design methods: lessons from medicineResearch in Engineering Design, 2006
- Experimental phased array radar ELRA with extended flexibilityIEEE Aerospace and Electronic Systems Magazine, 1990
- Theory of Technical Systems1988