Why Hasn't Integrated Health Care Developed Widely in the United States and Not at All in England?
Authors:
- Gwyn BevanGBGwyn Bevan
- Katharina JanusKJKatharina Janus
- 1 February 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Duke University Press in Journal of Health Politics, Policy and Law
- Vol. 36 (1) , 141-164
Abstract
There have been influential advocates for financing and organizing health care in the United States and England based on the model of integrated health care delivery systems (IHCDSs). Despite good evidence that a few IHCDSs provide high-quality health care economically, such organizations are rare and localized in a few market areas in the United States and are absent in the English National Health Service (NHS). The explanation of why this is so includes various contributory factors: the way the development of the medical profession in each country pursued specialization; the division in British medicine between general practitioners and specialists; and the characteristics that we identify of established successful IHCDSs, which created formidable barriers to entry for a new IHCDS. This explains why currently the most promising organizational developments in U.S. health care are hybrids resulting from vertical integration. In England government policies of an “internal market,” as adopted in the 1990s and currently, were and are based on a purchaser-provider split with the objectives that providers would compete and be funded by a system in which “money follows the patient.” These policies recognize the division in British medicine, which also means that it is difficult to implement a reorganized English NHS based on high-performing IHCDSs.Keywords
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Will polyclinics deliver real benefits for patients? NoBMJ, 2008
- Will polyclinics deliver real benefits for patients? YesBMJ, 2008
- Competition and integration in the English National Health ServiceBMJ, 2008
- Seven years of feast, seven years of famine: boom to bust in the NHS?BMJ, 2006
- Working for PatientsJournal of the Royal Society of Health, 1992
- The doctor, the patient, and their contract. III. Alternative contracts: are they viable?BMJ, 1986
- COMPARISON OF HEALTH OUTCOMES AT A HEALTH MAINTENANCE ORGANISATION WITH THOSE OF FEE-FOR-SERVICE CAREThe Lancet, 1986
- Organising the Finance of Hospitals by Simulated MarketsFiscal Studies, 1984
- A Controlled Trial of the Effect of a Prepaid Group Practice on Use of ServicesNew England Journal of Medicine, 1984
- Consumer-Choice Health PlanNew England Journal of Medicine, 1978