A Comparison of the Incidence and Understanding of Altitude Illness Between Porters and Trekkers in the Solu Khumbu Region of Nepal
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 September 2011
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Wilderness & Environmental Medicine
- Vol. 22 (3) , 197-201
Abstract
Objective: Altitude illness can occur in anyone who ascends to high altitude. Better understanding of altitude illness is associated with a lower incidence of acute mountain sickness (AMS). The purpose of this study is to compare, for the first time, the incidence and understanding of altitude illness between foreign trekkers and indigenous porters in Nepal. Methods: Interviews and questionnaires were completed at the International Porter Protection Group Rescue Post at Machermo (4470 m). Participants completed the Lake Louise acute mountain sickness self-assessment questionnaire. They were also asked about their actions in response to high altitude illness scenarios as well as their perception of the vulnerability of porters vs trekkers to altitude illness. Ascent profile, age, gender, ethnic origin, and altitude of home residence were also obtained. Results: Trekkers ( n=131) had a significantly higher incidence of AMS (21% vs 8%) than porters ( n=92; P < .02). Lowland porters (whose home villages were below 3050 m, n=61) had a numerically higher, though not significantly different, incidence of AMS (10% vs 3%) compared to highland porters ( n=31). The majority of trekkers and porters recognized the symptoms of altitude illness and the most appropriate action to be taken. Despite the lower incidence of AMS in porters, around half felt that they were at greater risk than trekkers. Conclusions: Porters had a lower incidence of AMS, which may be attributable to repeated ascents through the trekking season, or differences in reporting symptoms. Both trekkers and porters demonstrated appropriate knowledge of actions to be taken in response to altitude illness.Keywords
This publication has 12 references indexed in Scilit:
- Wilderness Medical Society Consensus Guidelines for the Prevention and Treatment of Acute Altitude IllnessWilderness & Environmental Medicine, 2010
- Acute Mountain Sickness in Children at 4380 Meters in the HimalayasWilderness & Environmental Medicine, 2009
- The cerebral effects of ascent to high altitudesThe Lancet Neurology, 2009
- Update on High-Altitude Pulmonary Edema: Pathogenesis, Prevention, and TreatmentWilderness & Environmental Medicine, 2008
- Are We Doing Our Best to Educate Travelers About the Risks of Acute Mountain Sickness? An On?Site Prospective Study in the HimalayasJournal of Travel Medicine, 2007
- Mountain Sickness Knowledge Among Foreign Travelers in Cuzco, Peru☆Wilderness & Environmental Medicine, 2007
- Symptoms of Acute Mountain Sickness in Sherpas Exposed to Extremely High AltitudeHigh Altitude Medicine & Biology, 2006
- Prevention of Acute Mountain Sickness by Acetazolamide in Nepali Porters: A Double-Blind Controlled TrialWilderness & Environmental Medicine, 2006
- Medical problems of porters and trekkers in the Nepal HimalayaWilderness & Environmental Medicine, 1997
- THE INCIDENCE, IMPORTANCE, AND PROPHYLAXIS OF ACUTE MOUNTAIN SICKNESSThe Lancet, 1976