We examine the heterogeneous effects of Federal Reserve forward guidance on equity returns. Using structural high-frequency shocks identified by Jarociński (2024), we distinguish between Delphic and Odyssean forward guidance and estimate their dynamic effects on equity returns. Consistent with flight-to-safety mechanisms, we find that Delphic forward guidance shocks generate significant response heterogeneity across Fama-French portfolios. For instance, during 'risk-off' episodes, profitability is favored over firm size. By contrast, Odyssean forward guidance produces largely symmetric responses across all portfolios. We link the muted heterogeneity of responses to Odyssean shocks to highly informed and efficient markets. Our results have important implications for portfolio managers aiming to hedge against policy-induced uncertainty, and for policymakers designing communication strategies that acknowledge the heterogeneous transmission of forward guidance across firms.