EFFECTS OF MAPPING STRATEGIES ON READING COMPREHENSION AND WRITING PERFORMANCE

Authors:

Abstract
Three studies were conducted to examine the extent to which mapping strategies used in conjunction with basal reader stories enhanced the comprehension and writing performance of fifth-grade students. In Experiment 1, significant differences on a reading comprehension measure were found in favor of a group receiving key concept mapping strategies when compared to a control group, but no differences were found in the overall quality of compositions produced (N =30). The key-concept mapping strategy was found to work particularly well for those types of reading selections that were factual/informative in nature. Experiment 2 expanded the previous study to 80 subjects drawn from eight classrooms. In this study, the stories mapped were restricted to factual/informative type selections. A detailed scoring guide was developed in an attempt to pick up any differences in writing produced by the students. Again, significant differences were found on the reading comprehension measure, but no differences were found in the compositions produced. Experiment 3 was designed to test the effectiveness of literary mapping strategies when used with narrative type reading selections. No differences were found between the mapping group and control group on either reading comprehension or writing produced. Conclusions are that key concept mapping is a particularly powerful tool for enhancing reading comprehension of factual/informative reading selections; literary mapping strategies may present a viable alternative to inject variety into the reading lesson; and, any improvement in writing performance may require more long term intervention or direct instruction.

This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit: