Student perceptions of flexible learning in Philippine higher education during COVID-19 and implications for crisis-responsive monitoring

Authors:

Abstract
Flexible learning system (FLS) became a centerpiece continuity strategy among Philippine higher education institutions during COVID−19. However, its structure and variations across groups of students were unknown. Data were collected from a sample of 12,525 students across higher education institutions in Luzon, Visayas, and Mindanao to study psychometric properties of an FLS questionnaire and relationship of retained domain scores to student profile and teaching-learning technology variables. Sample largely consisted of female respondents (67.5%), individuals who utilized a learning management system during the pandemic (57.9%), and individuals with slow internet connectivity (57.8%) while only 11.8% had fast internet connectivity. Results from our exploratory study provided support for the four-domain structure (Support, Resources and Digital Proficiency, Readiness for Self-Regulated Learning, Barriers and Challenges) which showed good factorability [KMO = 0.944; Bartlett's χ ²(325) = 178,200, p < 0.001]. Confirmatory factor analysis indicated model fit was better than a one-factor model, however fit indices were not ideal (CFI = 0.850, TLI = 0.834, RMSEA = 0.098, SRMR = 0.071). Internal consistency was strong for Support ( α = 0.862), Resources and Digital Proficiency ( α = 0.824), and Readiness ( α = 0.832), but weaker for Barriers ( α = 0.658). In FDR-adjusted HC3-robust multivariable models, poor vs. fast internet was associated with lower Resources (B = −0.542, p < 0.001) and lower Readiness (B = −0.172, p < 0.001). In contrast, higher digital literacy and prior LMS experience were associated with more favorable scores across several domains (all p < 0.05, FDR-adjusted). Qualitative themes identified connectivity as the dominant challenge (69.6%), while better understanding or learning effectiveness (32.0%) and accessibility or convenience (14.6%) shaped preferred modes of instruction. Overall, FLS during the COVID-19 period was workable but uneven, with support and learner persistence rated more favorably than resource sufficiency and barrier relief. The instrument may serve as a low-stakes institutional monitoring tool during COVID-analogous disruptions, although the Barriers domain still requires refinement and revalidation.

This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit: