Pancreatic Resection Versus Peritoneal Lavage in Acute Necrotizing Pancreatitis
Authors:
- V. SainioVSV. Sainio
- L. KivisaariLKL. Kivisaari
- P. PuolakkainenPPP. Puolakkainen
- E. KivilaaksoEKE. Kivilaakso
- M. LempinenMLM. Lempinen
- 1 December 1991
- journal article
- clinical trial
- Published by Wolters Kluwer Health in Annals of Surgery
- Vol. 214 (6) , 663-666
Abstract
Twenty-one patients with acute fulminant alcoholic pancreatitis were randomly allocated to either pancreatic resection group (11 patients) or nonoperative peritoneal lavage group (10 patients). Only patients under 50 years were included in the study to minimize the role of other severe disease. These patients represented the most severe cases of acute pancreatitis at our Department, constituting only 2% of all patients with acute pancreatitis during this period. The diagnosis was based on clinical symptoms and on signs indicating severely impaired systemic organ functions. All patients underwent contrast-enhanced computed tomography (CT), which showed contrast enhancement below 30 Hounsfield units. In the operated cases, the diagnosis of necrotizing pancreatitis was verified histologically. All patients with conservative treatment had dark brown fluid at peritoneal puncture. There was a difference (nonsignificant) in mortality (3/11 and 1/10, respectively), complication rate, or in the need of reoperations between the groups. Nonoperative peritoneal lavage was followed with shorter treatment at the intensive care unit (16.2 versus 25.9 days, respectively). The hospital stay also was significantly shorter in the nonoperative group (44.3 versus 56.1 days). The results indicate that intensive conservative treatment is justified as an initial therapy even in the most severe cases of acute pancreatitis.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bacterial contamination of pancreatic necrosisGastroenterology, 1986
- EFFECTS OF DEXTRAN 70 VERSUS CRYSTALLOIDS IN THE MICROCIRCULATION OF PORCINE HEMORRHAGIC-PANCREATITIS1986
- Results of surgical treatment of necrotizing pancreatitisWorld Journal of Surgery, 1985
- Significance of extrapancreatic findings in computed tomography (CT) of acute pancreatitis.1985
- Controlled Clinical Trial of Peritoneal Lavage for the Treatment of Severe Acute PancreatitisNew England Journal of Medicine, 1985
- Open treatment of pancreatic abscess.1984
- A new method for the diagnosis of acute hemorrhagic-necrotizing pancreatitis using contrast-enhanced CTGastrointestinal Radiology, 1984
- Pancreatic Resection versus Peritoneal Lavation for Acute Fulminant PancreatitisAnnals of Surgery, 1984
- Peritoneal lavage in severe acute pancreatitis.1984
- Early Detection of Acute Fulminant Pancreatitis by Contrast-Enhanced Computed TomographyScandinavian Journal of Gastroenterology, 1983