Commercial living non-related organ transplantation: a viewpoint from a developed country
- 1 October 2006
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Pediatric Nephrology
- Vol. 21 (10) , 1364-1368
Abstract
In developed countries, the use of living unrelated donors is restricted to purely altruistic donors who have a close and emotional relationship with the recipients. By law, commercial transplantation is illegal. Increasing shortness of donors, the excellent results of kidney transplants from spousal and living unrelated donors as well as the very low risk for the donor has been used as an argument for paid organ donation. Arguments in favour are the relief of donor-organ shortage, short waiting times for renal transplantation, economic benefits for the donor as well as the economic benefits for society by reducing the costs of dialysis by more transplants. Major arguments against are exploitation of the donor, coercion, and a growing black market. Despite the fact that different societies have different norms or reproaches that we are failing our patients and accept the death of thousands, kidney trade has created an environment of corruption and commercialisation, which brings even the cadaver transplant program into disrepute. However, denying the existence of paid organ donation does not contribute to solve the problem. A public discussion about consequences of changing ethics and human rights, rather than pragmatic solutions, is needed.Keywords
This publication has 23 references indexed in Scilit:
- Incentive Models to Increase Living Kidney Donation:Encouraging Without CoercingAmerican Journal of Transplantation, 2005
- Ethics of paid organ donationPediatric Nephrology, 2002
- Outcome of living unrelated (commercial) renal transplantationKidney International, 2001
- Against paid organ donationTransplantation Proceedings, 2001
- Kidney Transplantation from Living Unrelated DonorsAnnual Review of Medicine, 2000
- Ethics of paid organ donation and the use of executed prisoners as donors: A dialectic with Professors Cameron and HoffenbergKidney International, 1999
- Paid organ donation--the grey basket concept.Journal of Medical Ethics, 1998
- The ethics of organ donationBritish Medical Bulletin, 1997
- Outcome of Commercial Renal Transplantation: Two Years Follow-UpNephron, 1996
- High Survival Rates of Kidney Transplants from Spousal and Living Unrelated DonorsNew England Journal of Medicine, 1995