Distinguishing Between Investigator Discriminability and Eyewitness Discriminability: A Method for Creating Full Receiver Operating Characteristic Curves of Lineup Identification Performance
Authors:
- 6 May 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Perspectives on Psychological Science
- Vol. 15 (3) , 589-607
Abstract
The conceptual frameworks provided by both the lineups-as-experiments analogy and signal detection theory have proven important to understanding how eyewitness lineups work. The lineups-as-experiments analogy proposes that when investigators use a lineup procedure, they are acting as experimenters and should therefore follow the same tried-and-true procedures that experimenters follow when executing an experiment. Signal detection theory offers a framework for distinguishing between factors that improve the trade-off between culprit and innocent-suspect identifications and factors that affect the frequency of suspect identifications. We integrate these two conceptual frameworks. We argue that an eyewitness lineup procedure is characterized by two simultaneous signal detection tasks. On one hand, the witness is tasked with determining whether the culprit is present in the lineup and identifying that person. On the other hand, the investigator knows which lineup member is the suspect and which lineup members are known-innocent fillers and is therefore tasked only with determining whether the suspect is the culprit. The investigator uses the witness’s identification decision and associated level of confidence to decide whether the suspect is the culprit. We leverage this realization to demonstrate a method for creating full receiver operating characteristic curves for eyewitness lineup procedures.Keywords
Funding Information
- Laura and John Arnold Foundation (400-61-12c)
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Costs and Benefits of Eyewitness Identification ReformPerspectives on Psychological Science, 2012
- Developing Non-Arbitrary Metrics for Risk Communication: Percentile Ranks for the Static-99/R and Static-2002/R Sexual Offender Risk ToolsInternational Journal of Forensic Mental Health, 2012
- Diagnostic Performance of Digital versus Film Mammography for Breast-Cancer ScreeningNew England Journal of Medicine, 2005
- A memory and decision model for eyewitness identificationApplied Cognitive Psychology, 2003
- ABC of breast diseases: Breast cancer---epidemiology, risk factors, and geneticsBMJ, 2000
- "Good, you identified the suspect": Feedback to eyewitnesses distorts their reports of the witnessing experience.Journal of Applied Psychology, 1998
- Social influence in eyewitness recall: A meta-analytic review of lineup instruction effects.Law and Human Behavior, 1997
- Police Lineups as ExperimentsPersonality and Social Psychology Bulletin, 1990
- Eyewitness identification: The importance of lineup models.Psychological Bulletin, 1986
- On estimating the diagnosticity of eyewitness nonidentifications.Psychological Bulletin, 1980