Teacher Bias in Assessments by Student Ascribed Status: A Factorial Experiment on Discrimination in Education
Open Access
- 1 January 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Society for Sociological Science in Sociological Science
- Vol. 11, 743-776
Abstract
Teachers are the evaluators of academic merit. Identifying if their assessments are fair or biased by student-ascribed status is critical for equal opportunity but empirically challenging, with mixed previous findings. We test status characteristics beliefs, statistical discrimination, and cultural capital theories with a pre-registered factorial experiment on a large sample of Spanish pre-service teachers (n = 1, 717). This design causally identifies, net of ability, the impact of student-ascribed characteristics on teacher short- and long-term assessments, improving prior studies' theory testing, confounding, and power. Findings unveil teacher bias in an essay grading task favoring girls and highbrow cultural capital, aligning with status characteristics and cultural capital theories. Results on teachers' long-term expectations indicate statistical discrimination against boys, migrant origin, and working-class students under uncertain information. Unexpectedly, ethnic discrimination changes from teachers favoring native origin in long-term expectations to migrant origin in short-term evaluations, suggesting compensatory grading. We discuss the complex roots of discrimination in teacher assessments as an educational (in)equality mechanism.Keywords
This publication has 92 references indexed in Scilit:
- Changing preservice teacher students’ stereotypes and attitudes and reducing judgment biases concerning students of different family backgrounds: Effects of a short interventionSocial Psychology of Education, 2023
- Assessing knowledge or classroom behavior? Evidence of teachers’ grading biasJournal of Public Economics, 2022
- Equally performing, unfairly evaluatedResearch in Social Stratification and Mobility, 2022
- Cultural Assimilation and Ethnic Discrimination: An Audit Study with SchoolsLabour Economics, 2021
- Ethnic and social class discrimination in education: Experimental evidence from GermanyResearch in Social Stratification and Mobility, 2020
- Track recommendation bias: Gender, migration background and SES bias over a 20‐year period in the Dutch contextBritish Educational Research Journal, 2018
- Cultural capital, teacher bias, and educational success: New evidence from monozygotic twinsSocial Science Research, 2017
- Immigration as a Threat: Explaining the Changing Pattern of Xenophobia in SpainJournal of International Migration and Integration, 2015
- Stereotype activation versus application: how teachers process and judge information about students from ethnic minorities and with low socioeconomic backgroundSocial Psychology of Education, 2014
- Highbrow omnivorousness on the small screen?Poetics, 2009