The inadequacy of statistical approaches to estimate yield potential and gaps at regional level
Preprint
- 3 May 2024
- preprint
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Abstract
Spatial information on yield potential is key to determine crop production potential on existing cropland. Although statistical methods are widely used to estimate yield potential and yield gaps at regional to global levels, a rigorous evaluation of their performance is lacking. Here, we compared outcomes from three common statistical approaches against those derived from a ‘bottom-up’ approach based on crop modeling and local weather and soil data for major crops in the United States. Our analysis revealed that statistical methods failed to capture the spatial variation in yield potential, consistently under- or over-estimating yield gaps across various regions. The statistical methods led to conflicting results for decision-making, with production potential almost doubling from one method to another. Given these limitations, we advocate for the use of well-validated process-based crop models coupled with local data and robust spatial frameworks, which provide a more reliable assessment of crop production potential from local to regional scales.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Version 1, 2024-05-03, Research Square
- Published version: Nature Food, 6 (7), 715.
This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit:
- Assessing environment types for maize, soybean, and wheat in the United States as determined by spatio-temporal variation in drought and heat stressAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2021
- Spatiotemporal trends in crop yields, yield variability, and yield gaps across the USACrop Science, 2020
- Predicting crop yields and soil‐plant nitrogen dynamics in the US Corn BeltCrop Science, 2020
- Maize root distributions strongly associated with water tables in Iowa, USAPlant and Soil, 2019
- Water productivity of rainfed maize and wheat: A local to global perspectiveAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2018
- Assessing causes of yield gaps in agricultural areas with diversity in climate and soilsAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2017
- Vulnerability of grain crops and croplands in the Midwest to climatic variability and adaptation strategiesClimatic Change, 2017
- Creating long-term weather data from thin air for crop simulation modelingAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2015
- High-yield maize–soybean cropping systems in the US Corn Belt2015
- APSIM: a novel software system for model development, model testing and simulation in agricultural systems researchAgricultural Systems, 1996