A Life Worth Giving? The Threshold for Permissible Withdrawal of Life Support From Disabled Newborn Infants
Open Access
- 14 February 2011
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The American Journal of Bioethics
- Vol. 11 (2) , 20-32
Abstract
When is it permissible to allow a newborn infant to die on the basis of their future quality of life? The prevailing official view is that treatment may be withdrawn only if the burdens in an infant's future life outweigh the benefits. In this paper I outline and defend an alternative view. On the Threshold View, treatment may be withdrawn from infants if their future well-being is below a threshold that is close to, but above the zero-point of well-being. I present four arguments in favor of the Threshold View, and identify and respond to several counterarguments. I conclude that it is justifiable in some circumstances for parents and doctors to decide to allow an infant to die even though the infant's life would be worth living. The Threshold View provides a justification for treatment decisions that is more consistent, more robust, and potentially more practical than the standard view.Keywords
This publication has 81 references indexed in Scilit:
- Moral Status As a Matter of Degree?The Southern Journal of Philosophy, 2008
- The baby MB case: medical decision making in the context of uncertain infant sufferingJournal of Medical Ethics, 2007
- Legal basis for ethical withholding and withdrawing life‐sustaining medical treatment from infants and childrenJournal of Paediatrics and Child Health, 2007
- The Best Interests Standard for Incompetent or Incapacitated Persons of All AgesJournal of Law, Medicine & Ethics, 2007
- Is it in the best interests of an intellectually disabled infant to die?Journal of Medical Ethics, 2006
- Death in the neonatal intensive care unit: changing patterns of end of life care over two decadesArchives of Disease in Childhood - Fetal and Neonatal Edition, 2006
- Selecting Disability and the Welfare of the ChildThe Monist, 2006
- Drawing Abilities in Williams Syndrome: A Case StudyDevelopmental Neuropsychology, 2000
- Deciding for OthersThe Milbank Quarterly, 1986
- Wrongful Life and the Counterfactual Element in HarmingSocial Philosophy and Policy, 1986