Towards a Systematic Screening Tool for Quality Assurance and Semiautomatic Fraud Detection for Images in the Life Sciences
Open Access
- 15 November 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Science and Engineering Ethics
- Vol. 23 (4) , 1113-1128
Abstract
The quality and authenticity of images is essential for data presentation, especially in the life sciences. Questionable images may often be a first indicator for questionable results, too. Therefore, a tool that uses mathematical methods to detect suspicious images in large image archives can be a helpful instrument to improve quality assurance in publications. As a first step towards a systematic screening tool, especially for journal editors and other staff members who are responsible for quality assurance, such as laboratory supervisors, we propose a basic classification of image manipulation. Based on this classification, we developed and explored some simple algorithms to detect copied areas in images. Using an artificial image and two examples of previously published modified images, we apply quantitative methods such as pixel-wise comparison, a nearest neighbor and a variance algorithm to detect copied-and-pasted areas or duplicated images. We show that our algorithms are able to detect some simple types of image alteration, such as copying and pasting background areas. The variance algorithm detects not only identical, but also very similar areas that differ only by brightness. Further types could, in principle, be implemented in a standardized scanning routine. We detected the copied areas in a proven case of image manipulation in Germany and showed the similarity of two images in a retracted paper from the Kato labs, which has been widely discussed on sites such as pubpeer and retraction watch.Keywords
This publication has 21 references indexed in Scilit:
- La fraude en cancérologieOncologie, 2010
- The Hwang Scandal and Korean News Coverage: Ethical ConsiderationsJournal of Mass Media Ethics, 2010
- A false sense of securityJournal of Cell Biology, 2008
- Don't Pretty Up That Picture Just YetScience, 2006
- Cleaning Up the Paper TrailScience, 2006
- Fraud Upends Oral Cancer Field, Casting Doubt on Prevention TrialScience, 2006
- Doctor admits Lancet study is fiction2006
- Cytokines suppress adipogenesis and PPAR-γ function through the TAK1/TAB1/NIK cascadeNature Cell Biology, 2003
- Dubious data remain in print two years after misconduct inquiryNature, 2002
- Forensic Examination of Questioned Scientific ImagesAccountability in Research, 2002