A Meta-Analytical Review of Teacher Credibility and its Associations with Teacher Behaviors and Student Outcomes

Authors:
  • PSPaul Schrodt
    Paul Schrodt
  • PWPaul L. Witt
    Paul L. Witt
  • NENikki Elledge
    Nikki Elledge
  • KJKodiane A. Jernberg
    Kodiane A. Jernberg
  • LLLara M. Larson
    Lara M. Larson

Abstract
This meta-analysis reviews the findings of 51 studies (N = 14,378) examining the associations among teacher credibility, teacher behaviors, and student outcomes. When all three dimensions of credibility are considered collectively (i.e., competence, trustworthiness, and caring), the cumulative evidence indicates a moderate, meaningful relationship between teacher credibility and overall outcomes (r=.448). Similar overall effect sizes were observed for competence (r=.481), trustworthiness (r=.477), and caring (r=.554), though the overall effect size for caring was greater in magnitude than that obtained for credibility measured as a single factor (r=.294). On average, higher correlations were observed when researchers measured all three dimensions of credibility (r=.518) than when they only measured competence and character (r=.256). Collectively, the results highlight the unique contributions of perceived caring to the teacher credibility construct, as well as the meaningful role that teacher credibility plays in facilitating student learning.

This publication has 70 references indexed in Scilit: