Social insurance determines social and economic characteristics of the population, including health, income, and employment. We expand the research into the returns of EU social insurance on citizens' well-being. We assess with multilevel modeling the hierarchical relationship between financing (coverage) and social outcomes of social insurance and their impact on well-being indicators: happiness, life satisfaction, and trust in others. We find the largest contribution of finance through per capita social transfers across all observed social insurance programs. In contrast, financing through GDP expenditures is statistically significant only for unemployment insurance. Although the three models of different welfare measures are valid, they differ in the impact of social insurance on well-being. Social support for people with disabilities and perceived healthy life expectancy are most significant for happiness, perceived healthy life expectancy is also most significant for life satisfaction, and health-related absenteeism and transition from unemployment to employment are most significant for trust in others. According to the value of 𝛽-coefficients, perceived healthy life expectancy is the strongest characteristic and is the most important indicator of social insurance for well-being. We contribute to the understanding of the hierarchical influence of financing and social outcomes of social insurance on well-being, suggesting social policy implications.