Modelling earthquake location errors at a reservoir scale: a case study in the Upper Rhine Graben
- 12 May 2016
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Geophysical Journal International
- Vol. 206 (2) , 861-879
Abstract
Earthquake absolute location errors which can be encountered in an underground reservoir are investigated. In such an exploitation context, earthquake hypocentre errors can have an impact on the field development and economic consequences. The approach using state-of-the-art techniques covers both the location uncertainty and the location inaccuracy – or bias – problematics. It consists, first, in creating a 3D synthetic seismic cloud of events in the reservoir and calculating the seismic travel times to a monitoring network assuming certain propagation conditions. In a second phase, the earthquakes are relocated with assumptions different from the initial conditions. Finally, the initial and relocated hypocentres are compared. As a result, location errors driven by the seismic onset time picking uncertainties and inaccuracies are quantified in 3D. Effects induced by erroneous assumptions associated with the velocity model are also modelled. In particular, 1D velocity model uncertainties, a local 3D perturbation of the velocity and a 3D geo-structural model are considered. The present approach is applied to the site of Rittershoffen (Alsace, France), which is one of the deep geothermal fields existing in the Upper Rhine Graben. This example allows setting realistic scenarios based on the knowledge of the site. In that case, the zone of interest, monitored by an existing seismic network, ranges between 1 and 5 km depth in a radius of 2 km around a geothermal well. Well log data provided a reference 1D velocity model used for the synthetic earthquake relocation. The 3D analysis highlights the role played by the seismic network coverage and the velocity model in the amplitude and orientation of the location uncertainties and inaccuracies at subsurface levels. The location errors are neither isotropic nor aleatoric in the zone of interest. This suggests that although location inaccuracies may be smaller than location uncertainties, both quantities can have a cumulative effect. Besides, small velocity uncertainties applied to the whole 1D profile can lead to large increase of the location uncertainties. However, local variations of the velocity field around the well may have negligible effects that would make such a feature undetectable with an absolute location method. Although the reference 1D velocity model was built from well log data, the results show that it is not a good representative of a more realistic 3D model including a fault and its associated block shift. The amplitude and distribution of the induced location inaccuracies are such that the positioning and the orientation of features delineated by seismicity are distorted and may be difficult to correctly interpret.Keywords
This publication has 42 references indexed in Scilit:
- New stratigraphic interpretation of the Soultz-sous-Forêts 30-year-old geothermal wells calibrated on the recent one from Rittershoffen (Upper Rhine Graben, France)Geothermal Energy, 2016
- Induced seismicity in geothermal reservoirs: A review of forecasting approachesRenewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 2015
- Seismic monitoring and analysis of deep geothermal projects in St Gallen and Basel, SwitzerlandGeophysical Journal International, 2015
- Detection and Delineation of a Fracture Zone with Observation of Seismic Shear Wave Anisotropy in the Upper Rhine Graben, SW GermanyPure and Applied Geophysics, 2014
- Coalescence microseismic mappingGeophysical Journal International, 2013
- Localization of temperature anomalies in the Upper Rhine Graben: insights from geophysics and neotectonic activityInternational Geology Review, 2013
- Large-scale aseismic motion identified through 4-D P-wave tomographyGeophysical Journal International, 2011
- Constrained tomography of realistic velocity models in microseismic monitoring using calibration shotsGeophysical Prospecting, 2010
- Seismic response of the fractured and faulted granite of Soultz-sous-Forêts (France) to 5 km deep massive water injectionsGeophysical Journal International, 2009
- How close to failure is a granite rock mass at a 5km depth?International Journal of Rock Mechanics and Mining Sciences, 2007