A Bayesian meta-analysis of the effects of administering an intra-vaginal (CIDR) device in combination with other hormones on the reproductive performance of cycling, anoestrous and inseminated cows
Authors:
- 1 December 2004
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in New Zealand Veterinary Journal
- Vol. 52 (6) , 384-393
Abstract
AIMS: To evaluate the effectiveness of treatment programmes that included controlled internal drug-releasing (CIDR) devices containing progesterone (P4) in improving synchrony of oe- strus, and conception and pregnancy rates in cycling, anoestrous and inseminated dairy cows, using meta-analysis. To describe the difference in response between cycling and anoestrous cows to CIDR-based synchrony programmes. METHODS: Scientifi c papers written in the English language between 1989 and 2002 that investigated the effects of treat- ment programmes including CIDR devices on reproductive per- formance in dairy heifers or lactating dairy cows were identifi ed using a computerised literature search. The criteria for inclusion incorporated evidence that treatment allocation was completely randomised; the population studied was lactating dairy cows; and that data were available on submission, conception and pregnancy rates and their associated measures of variability. Re- productive outcomes from 25 synchrony trials (total n=11,058 cows) were analysed. Summary measures of the effect of treat- ment on reproductive outcome were assessed using fi xed- and random-effects Bayesian meta-analysis models. RESULTS: Treatment programmes including a CIDR device increased the risk of submission in cycling cows (predicted Baye- sian RR=2.86, 95% credible interval=1.46-5.67). Compared with controls, synchrony programmes including CIDR devices in cycling dairy cows had no effect on the risk of conception to fi rst service post-treatment (predicted Bayesian RR=1.00, 95% credible interval=0.80-1.24). Compared with controls, synchrony programmes including CIDR devices had no effect on the risk of pregnancy throughout the mating period (pre- dicted Bayesian RR=1.02, 95% credible interval=0.89-1.17). In anoestrous cows, CIDR treatment had no effect on the risk of conception to fi rst service post-treatment and no effect on the risk of pregnancy throughout the mating period, compared with anoestrous, untreated controls (predicted Bayesian RR=0.91 and 0.97, respectively; 95% credible interval=0.68-1.26 and 0.59-1.60, respectively). CONCLUSION: The results of this meta-analysis showed that synchrony programmes using CIDR devices combined with other hormones reliably enhanced submission rates in lactat- ing dairy cows. The relatively small number of trials with data suitable for analysis and the heterogeneity of results at the indi- vidual trial level limited our ability to confi rm either a benefi cial or deleterious effect of treatment on conception or pregnancy rates. Further randomised, controlled trials to evaluate the ef- fectiveness of this form of reproductive therapy in commercial dairy farms are needed.Keywords
This publication has 47 references indexed in Scilit:
- Meta-Analysis of Migraine Headache Treatments: Combining Information from Heterogeneous DesignsJournal of the American Statistical Association, 1999
- Body condition influences maintenance of a persistent first wave dominant follicle in dairy cattleTheriogenology, 1998
- Selection of the Dominant Follicle in Cattle1Biology of Reproduction, 1996
- Embryonic ability to prolong the interoestrous interval in virgin and repeat breeder heifersAnimal Reproduction Science, 1991
- Interrelationships Between Energy Balance and Postpartum Reproductive Function in Dairy CattleJournal of Dairy Science, 1989
- Evidence for maternal regulation of early conceptus growth and development in beef cattleReproduction, 1988
- Effect of exogenous progesterone on prostaglandin F2α release and the interestrous interval in the bovineProstaglandins, 1988
- Effect of body condition at calving and level of feeding in early lactation on milk production of dairy cowsAnimal Production Science, 1982
- Profiles of reproductive hormones associated with fertile and nonfertile inseminations of dairy cowsTheriogenology, 1976
- The anoestrous syndrome in New Zealand dairy cattleNew Zealand Veterinary Journal, 1973