Human verifications: Computable with truth values outside logic
Open Access
- 25 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by National Academy of Sciences in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
- Vol. 120 (40)
Abstract
Cognitive scientists treat verification as a computation in which descriptions that match the relevant situation are true, but otherwise false. The claim is controversial: The logician Gödel and the physicist Penrose have argued that human verifications are not computable. In contrast, the theory of mental models treats verification as computable, but the two truth values of standard logics, true and false , as insufficient. Three online experiments (n = 208) examined participants’ verifications of disjunctive assertions about a location of an individual or a journey, such as: ‘You arrived at Exeter or Perth’. The results showed that their verifications depended on observation of a match with one of the locations but also on the status of other locations (Experiment 1). Likewise, when they reached one destination and the alternative one was impossible, their use of the truth value: could be true and could be false increased (Experiment 2). And, when they reached one destination and the only alternative one was possible, they used the truth value, true and it couldn’t have been false , and when the alternative one was impossible, they used the truth value: true but it could have been false (Experiment 3). These truth values and those for falsity embody counterfactuals. We implemented a computer program that constructs models of disjunctions, represents possible destinations, and verifies the disjunctions using the truth values in our experiments. Whether an awareness of a verification’s outcome is computable remains an open question.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Cognitive Dynamics of Negated Sentence VerificationCognitive Science, 2011
- Event-related Potential Correlates of Negation in a Sentence–Picture Verification ParadigmJournal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 2008
- Dual-Processing Accounts of Reasoning, Judgment, and Social CognitionAnnual Review of Psychology, 2008
- The Neural Bases of Strategy and Skill in Sentence–Picture VerificationCognitive Psychology, 2000
- Sentence comprehension: A psycholinguistic processing model of verification.Psychological Review, 1975
- Perceptual coding strategies in the formation and verification of descriptionsMemory & Cognition, 1974
- NEGATIVES: DENOTATION AND CONNOTATIONBritish Journal of Psychology, 1963
- Semantical Analysis of Modal Logic I Normal Modal Propositional CalculiMathematical Logic Quarterly, 1963
- The Semantic Conception of Truth: and the Foundations of SemanticsPhilosophy and Phenomenological Research, 1944
- I.—MATHEMATICAL PROOFMind, 1929