One topical fluoride (toothpastes, or mouthrinses, or gels, or varnishes) versus another for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents
- 26 January 2004
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews
- Vol. 2009 (1) , CD002780
Abstract
Topical fluorides in the form of toothpaste, mouthrinse, varnish and gel are effective caries preventive measures. However, there is uncertainty about the relative value of these interventions. To compare the effectiveness of one form of topical fluoride intervention with another when used for the prevention of dental caries in children. We searched the Cochrane Oral Health Group's Trials Register (May 2000), the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials (CENTRAL) (The Cochrane Library Issue 2, 2000), MEDLINE (1966 to January 2000), plus several other databases. We handsearched journals, reference lists of articles and contacted selected authors and manufacturers. Randomized or quasi-randomized controlled trials with blind outcome assessment, comparing fluoride varnish, gel, mouthrinse, or toothpaste with each other in children up to 16 years during at least 1 year. The main outcome was caries increment measured by the change in decayed, missing and filled tooth surfaces (D(M)FS). Inclusion decisions, quality assessment and data extraction were duplicated in a random sample of one third of studies, and consensus achieved by discussion or a third party. Authors were contacted for missing data. The primary measure of effect was the prevented fraction (PF) that is the difference in mean caries increments between the 'experimental' and 'control' groups expressed as a percentage of the mean increment in the control group. Random effects meta-analyses were performed where data could be pooled. There were 17 studies included, and 15 contributed data for the meta-analyses. Fluoride toothpaste was not significantly different from mouthrinse (pooled DMFS PF 0%; 95% CI, -18% to 19%; p = 0.94), or gel (pooled DMFS PF 0%; 95% CI, -21% to 21%; p = 1), or both gel and mouthrinse (pooled DMFS PF 1%; 95% CI, -13% to 14%; p = 0.94); heterogeneity was substantial. Results from the single trial comparing toothpaste with varnish (in deciduous teeth) were inconclusive (dfs PF 5%; CI not obtainable). The pooled results from the comparisons of fluoride varnish with mouthrinse was a non-significant difference favouring varnish (DMFS PF 10%; 95% CI, -12% to 32%; p = 0.40), but this result was not robust to sensitivity analysis performed, and heterogeneity was considerable. Results from the single trial comparing varnish with gel (14%, 95% CI, -12% to 40%; p = 0.30) and the single trial comparing gel with mouthrinse (-14% DMFS PF; 95% CI, -40% to 12%; p = 0.30) were inconclusive (favoured varnish and mouthrinse respectively). Fluoride toothpastes in comparison to mouthrinses or gels appear to have a similar degree of effectiveness for the prevention of dental caries in children. There is no clear suggestion that fluoride varnish is more effective than mouthrinses and the evidence for the comparative effectiveness of fluoride varnishes and gels, and mouthrinses and gels is inconclusive. No conclusions about adverse effects could be reached, because no data were reported on in the trials. Acceptance is likely to be greater for fluoride toothpaste.Keywords
This publication has 55 references indexed in Scilit:
- Fluoride mouthrinses for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents2003
- Fluoride gels for preventing dental caries in children and adolescents2002
- Fluoride Varnish versus Acidulated Phosphate Fluoride Gel: A 3-Year Clinical TrialCaries Research, 1995
- Effectiveness of fortnightly tooth brushing with amine fluorides in caries‐prone subjectsJournal of Oral Rehabilitation, 1991
- Caries Preventive Effect of Two Fluoride Varnishes and a Fluoride MouthrinseCaries Research, 1987
- Three‐year caries increments after fluoride rinses or topical applications with a fluoride varnishCommunity Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology, 1985
- Clinical effects of preventive regimens for young people in their early and middle teens in relation to previous experience with dental preventionActa Odontologica Scandinavica, 1984
- A Three-Year Clinical Study to Determine the Separate and Combined Caries-Inhibiting Effects of Sodium Monofluorophosphate Toothpaste and an Acidulated Phosphate-Fluoride GelCaries Research, 1978
- Effects of an Amine Fluoride Mouthrinse and Dentifrice on the Gingival Health and the Extent of Plaque of School ChildrenJournal of Periodontology, 1977
- A Statistical Confidence Interval for True Per Cent Reduction in Caries-Incidence StudiesJournal of Dental Research, 1965