This chapter develops a theory of hallucination with which to legitimate the disjunctivist claim that hallucinations may be indiscriminable from veridical perceptions while being a fundamentally different kind of mental state. It begins with a discussion of the concept of indiscriminability and goes on to develop a theory of hallucination that claims that hallucinations are experiences that lack phenomenal character, but that nonetheless lead subjects to believe that they see something. This theory is then defended against a range of objections and extended to deal with cases of animal hallucinations and resisted hallucinations—hallucinations in which subjects are aware of the misleading nature of their experiences.