The Identity Crisis of International Criminal Law
Author:
- Darryl RobinsonDRDarryl Robinson
- 1 December 2008
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Leiden Journal of International Law
- Vol. 21 (4) , 925-963
Abstract
The general narrative of international criminal law (ICL) declares that the system adheres in an exemplary manner to the fundamental principles of a liberal criminal justice system. Recent scholarship has increasingly questioned the adherence of various ICL doctrines to such principles. This article scrutinizes the discourse of ICL – the assumptions and forms of argumentation that are regarded as sound reasoning with appropriate liberal aims. This article argues that ICL, in drawing on national criminal law and international human rights law, absorbed contradictory assumptions and methods of reasoning. The article explores three modes by which the assumptions of human rights liberalism subtly undermine the criminal law liberalism to which the system aspires. These modes include interpretive approaches, substantive and structural conflation, and ideological assumptions. The identity crisis theory helps to explain how a system that strives to serve as a model for liberal criminal justice systems has come to embrace illiberal doctrines that contradict the system's fundamental principles.Keywords
This publication has 32 references indexed in Scilit:
- Liberal Values in International Criminal Law: A Critique of ErdemovicJournal of International Criminal Justice, 2008
- Joint Criminal Enterprise: Possibilities and LimitationsJournal of International Criminal Justice, 2005
- The International Criminal CourtJournal of International Criminal Justice, 2004
- The General Principles of International Criminal Law Set Out in Nuremberg, as Mirrored in the ICC StatuteJournal of International Criminal Justice, 2004
- The Pitfalls of Universal JurisdictionForeign Affairs, 2001
- The Shadow Side of Command ResponsibilityThe American Journal of Comparative Law, 2001
- What Do Judges and Justices Maximize? (The Same Thing Everybody Else Does)Supreme Court Economic Review, 1993
- Moral Responsibility in the Age of BureaucracyMichigan Law Review, 1992
- Convictions and Fair LabellingThe Cambridge Law Journal, 1983
- "Guilty Associations: Joint Criminal Enterprise, Command Responsibility, and the Development of International Criminal Law"