Abstract
Mentorship is supposed to be ballast, a steady hand on the rudder while someone learns to sail in heavy weather. In medicine and science, we romanticize this role. We picture the senior clinician who opens doors, the principal investigator who fights for a stipend, the professor who notices a spark and fans it. We tell trainees to "find a mentor." We rarely teach them what to do when the relationship curdles.On paper, mentorship works. A systematic review in JAMA linked mentoring to career guidance, research productivity, and grant success, even while highlighting heterogeneity and methodological limits across studies [1]. Qualitative work across academic health centers has mapped the features of both successful and failed pairings: clarity of expectations, aligned values, reciprocal commitment, and the mentor's willingness to spend social capital distinguish the former; opacity, misalignment, and one-sided commitment mark the latter [2]. Alongside these encouraging findings, a parallel literature documents negative mentoring experiences. Taxonomies of "harmful mentorship" describe neglect, manipulation, lack of expertise, and broader dysfunction [3]. Team-level research on psychological safety shows how fear of embarrassment or retaliation silences questions and concerns, undermining learning precisely where stakes are high [4]. In academic medicine, bullying, harassment, and discrimination are not rare outliers but documented, patterned phenomena that intersect with mentorship and training structures [5][6][7]. Sponsorship, the active use of influence to advance a junior colleague, is also unevenly distributed, with women and underrepresented groups often receiving less advocacy even when mentored [8,14]. Despite this accumulated knowledge, most institutional responses remain strangely generic: workshops, policy statements, aspirational values on websites. Trainees still lack a practical map for what to do when mentorship goes wrong: how to name what is happening, how to decide whether to repair, exit, or escalate, and what they can reasonably expect from institutions that claim to value mentoring.I have been mentoring medical scientists, physicians, biotechnologists and biologists for over two decades, in several countries. In that time, I have celebrated students who flourished with generous guidance and honest feedback, but I have also watched talented people shrink, stall, or quietly leave because a mentoring relationship went wrong. Many of them did not complain formally; they came to my office, or caught me in a corridor, and told me stories that sounded uncomfortably similar, no matter the country, specialty, or institution. I have also had to confront my own blind spots as a mentor. Moments when, under pressure for grants, papers, and committees, I postponed meetings too often, answered emails too late, or failed to use my position to open doors for someone who trusted me. This piece grows out of that mix of privilege and discomfort: the privilege of seeing so many careers from close range, and the discomfort of recognizing how easily a system like ours can turn good intentions into harm. This Opinion article sits at that junction. It weaves together composite vignettes that many in academic medicine will recognize with an explicit decision pathway for trainees and a simple institutional framework, COMPASS, that links everyday mentoring practices to structural levers and concrete metrics. The goal is not to re-describe the problem, but to move from lament to a testable playbook for safer, fairer academic training.The damage caused by harmful mentorship is often quiet before it becomes dramatic. The literature captures this duality: on average, mentoring has modestly positive effects, but negative or neglectful relationships can reverse that benefit completely [1,3,5].Consider a junior infectious diseases fellow paired with a renowned tuberculosis researcher. On paper, it looks ideal. The lab is high profile; the mentor is generous with ideas but largely absent in practice. Meetings slide, then disappear. Deadlines are flexible for the mentor but rigid for the fellow. Authorship remains a moving target discussed in passing, never in writing. Feedback arrives as late-night line edits with no real conversation about direction. No single episode feels catastrophic. Yet, by the end of the year, the fellow has a thin CV, a narrow skill set tied to the mentor's pipeline, and an expanding sense of dread. This is not cinematic abuse. It is neglect, and neglect is one of the most common negative mentoring experiences described by protégés [3].The consequences extend beyond individual morale. When overwork, public shaming, or chronic unavailability substitute for guidance, team learning collapses. Psychological safety, the shared belief that it is safe to take interpersonal risks, is a prerequisite for the rapid error detection and adaptation that good science requires [4]. In unsafe teams, people withhold dissent, soften inconvenient data, and keep nascent ideas to themselves. Science becomes more fragile just as the rhetoric about excellence becomes louder. Reviews of academic bullying in medical settings show how mistreatment correlates with burnout, mental health problems, and attrition, with trainees in oppressive environments more likely to abandon particular specialties or academic careers altogether [5].The cost is also cumulative and material. It appears as stalled manuscripts, missed funding cycles, lost introductions, and delayed independence. Careers do not usually derail in one dramatic moment; they bend slowly under the weight of repeated, preventable failures of supervision, sponsorship, and safety.Negative mentoring is not a single phenomenon. Classic work by Eby and colleagues organized protégés' reports into categories such as mentor distancing (being unavailable), manipulative behavior, lack of expertise, and general dysfunction [3]. Subsequent...
Funding Information
  • Fundação Oswaldo Cruz

This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit: