Exploring the Factors That Promote a Balance Between Academic Integrity and the Effective Use of GenAI Tools in Higher Education: A Systematic Review
Top Cited Papers
- 31 August 2025
- journal article
- review article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Computer Assisted Learning
- Vol. 41 (5)
Abstract
Background: This study explored the factors that influence the balance between academic integrity and the effective use of GenAI tools in higher education. It focused on the role of institutional guidelines in enhancing the responsible use of GenAI technologies to enhance academic integrity.Objectives: The study was theoretically grounded in the Technology Acceptance Model and the Theory of Planned Behaviour to investigate the factors that promote academic integrity in using GenAI tools (RQ1), their impact and institutional strategies to effectively mitigate ethical risks (RQ2) and the model practices to support the ethical and effective use in higher education (RQ3).Methods: The PRISMA framework was used to systematically review and thematically synthesise the results of 213 peer‐reviewed articles published between January 2021 and May 2025.Results: Finding indicates that academic support, defined by structured training, technical scaffolding, and perceived usefulness, is critical to enabling ethical GenAI use. Additionally, student self‐regulation, as influenced by behavioural control and goal setting, was associated with greater academic integrity in GenAI‐mediated learning. Whereas institutional policies varied widely, those with transparent, adaptive and discipline‐responsive governance frameworks more effectively mitigated academic misconduct. Indeed, the model practices included GenAI ethics committees, interactive GenAI literacy modules, and the developer‐educator collaborations to promote algorithmic transparency.Conclusions: A comprehensive systems‐based approach that encompasses academic support, self‐regulation and ethical guidelines is critical for the responsible use of GenAI tools in education. Hence, to preserve academic integrity while nurturing innovation, institutions should integrate GenAI ethics into curricular design, faculty development and cross‐sectoral policy frameworks. Future research may expand into multilingual and longitudinal analyses to support equitable and sustainable GenAI integration across diverse educational settings.Keywords
This publication has 275 references indexed in Scilit:
- Academic Integrity Within the Medical Curriculum in the Age of Generative Artificial IntelligenceHealth Science Reports, 2025
- The Promise and Pitfalls: A Literature Review of Generative Artificial Intelligence as a Learning Assistant in ICT EducationComputer Applications in Engineering Education, 2025
- Impact of artificial intelligence on future clinical pharmacy research and scholarshipJACCP: Journal of the American College of Clinical Pharmacy, 2025
- AI Transparency in Academic Search Systems: An Initial ExplorationProceedings of the Association for Information Science and Technology, 2024
- Evolving intersections: AI, disability, and academic integrity in higher educationNew Directions for Teaching and Learning, 2024
- Enhancing qualitative research in higher education assessment through generative AI integration: A path toward meaningful insights and a cautionary taleNew Directions for Teaching and Learning, 2024
- Why do students use ChatGPT? Answering through a triangulation approachComputers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 2024
- Introducing AI applications in engineering education (PBL): An implementation of power generation at minimum wind velocity and turbine faults classification using AIComputer Applications in Engineering Education, 2023
- AI proctoring for offline examinations with 2-Longitudinal-Stream Convolutional Neural NetworksComputers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 2022
- AI-Induced guidance: Preserving the optimal Zone of Proximal DevelopmentComputers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 2022