Monitoring the consensus or driving polarization? Comparing journalistic coverage of anti-Green pass and anti-war protests in France and Italy (2021–2024)
Authors:
- 13 March 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Media, War & Conflict
Abstract
This study analyzes how the Italian and French press covered dissenting voices and protest against Covid-19 restrictions in 2021–2022 and protests against military support for Ukraine in 2022–2024. Both Covid-19 emergency measures and military support of Ukraine were backed by broad coalitions comprising government and opposition parties in Western democracies. In both cases, dissenting voices were marginalized. Such a broad political and societal consensus in a situation of emergency poses a dilemma to the traditional watchdog function of journalism. On the one hand, journalists are expected to back mainstream political forces that stand up for public health and security. On the other hand, journalists should report critically on the opposition and cover minority positions, which in the case of anti-vaccination and anti-war protests are often branded as radical or extremist. Both the collaborative and the radical strategy are risky because they might undermine trust in journalism as a neutral mediator, activating processes of polarization and fragmentation of the public sphere. Based on the manual coding of a corpus of 790 articles from 12 newspapers, this study captures the diffusion of openly partisan and antagonistic stances among journalists targeting both anti-consensus and pro-consensus actors. The data show that the Italian debate is much more polarized than the French; however, in both cases, pro-consensus journalists show a much greater propensity to transgress the norms of impartial and independent journalism, compared to journalists criticizing the political consensus.Keywords
Funding Information
- Volkswagen Foundation (VALCON Projext)
This publication has 36 references indexed in Scilit:
- Is the Age of Impartial Journalism Over? The Neutrality Principle and Audience (Dis)trust in Mainstream NewsJournalism Studies, 2021
- Hot weather, hot topic. Polarization and sceptical framing in the climate debate on TwitterInformation, Communication & Society, 2020
- Truth is What Happens to NewsJournalism Studies, 2018
- The Audience-Oriented EditorDigital Journalism, 2018
- The Crisis of Public Communication, 1995–2017Javnost - The Public, 2018
- Dissonant and Disconnected Public Spheres as Challenge for Political Communication ResearchJavnost - The Public, 2018
- Towards A Typology of Conflict FramesJournalism Studies, 2017
- Journalism in the CrossfireJournalism Studies, 2016
- Comparing Media Systems2004
- The militarism of local television: The routine framing of the Persian Gulf warCritical Studies in Mass Communication, 1995