FINDING VALUE WHERE NONE EXISTS: PITFALLS IN USING ADJUSTED PRESENT VALUE
Author:
- 1 March 2002
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Corporate Finance
- Vol. 15 (1) , 95-104
Abstract
There are several conceptually “correct” methods for valuing firms and projects, including the weighted average cost of capital (WACC) approach, the flows to equity (FTE) method, and the adjusted present value (APV) or valuation‐by‐components method. The author examines the relative advantages of these frameworks and offers guidance as to when they are likely to be most useful. The key message is a caution to would‐be users of APV: it is frequently unreliable and should be used only in conjunction with more conventional valuation frameworks. It works best in transactions that involve structured financings, such as leveraged buyouts and project and real estate financings. Even in these cases, however, its usefulness depends on theoretical concepts that in practical applications have a wide margin of error.In general, WACC is a robust and appropriate valuation framework as long as the firm has a target debt ratio. The FTE method is most relevant for acquisitions and very large projects. The author shows how APV and FTE can be formulated to be consistent with the WACC valuation. The issue, however, is not whether the techniques can be made consistent through relatively complex adjustments by sophisticated users, but rather what happens when they are used in everyday applications by practitioners unfamiliar with the somewhat arcane valuation issues involved.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- TWO DCF APPROACHES FOR VALUING COMPANIES UNDER ALTERNATIVE FINANCING STRATEGIES (AND HOW TO CHOOSE BETWEEN THEM)Journal of Applied Corporate Finance, 1997
- HOW TO VALUE RECAPITALIZATIONS AND LEVERAGED BUYOUTSJournal of Applied Corporate Finance, 1989
- Tax Policy and Corporate SavingBrookings Papers on Economic Activity, 1987
- Capital Budgeting frameworks for the Multinational CorporationJournal of International Business Studies, 1982
- The Weighted Average Cost of Capital, Perfect Capital Markets, and Project Life: A ClarificationJournal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis, 1980
- Capital Budgeting and the Financing Decision: An ExpositionFinancial Management, 1977
- INTERACTIONS OF CORPORATE FINANCING AND INVESTMENT DECISIONS—IMPLICATIONS FOR CAPITAL BUDGETINGThe Journal of Finance, 1974
- THE EFFECT OF THE FIRM'S CAPITAL STRUCTURE ON THE SYSTEMATIC RISK OF COMMON STOCKSThe Journal of Finance, 1972