Quantifying neighbour effects on tree growth: Are common ‘competition’ indices biased?
Open Access
- 21 March 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Ecology
- Vol. 111 (6) , 1270-1280
Abstract
Interactions among neighbouring plants are key determinants of plant growth. To characterise the cumulative effect of all neighbours on the growth of a focal plant, neighbourhoods are often described by ‘competition’ indices. Common competition indices calculate the summed size of neighbour plants (focal‐independent index [FII]) whilst others include the summed ratio of the neighbour size relative to focal plant size (focal dependent). A frequently overlooked statistical artefact is that focal‐dependent indices (FDIs) may lead to biased estimates of neighbourhood effects on plant growth when growth is size dependent. Here, we conduct a literature search to determine the most common index types used to explain neighbour effects on tree growth. We then assess the ability of two common index types—focal dependent and focal independent—to correctly infer neighbourhood effects in (1) observations of tree growth in an experimental forest in south‐east Tasmania, Australia, and (2) an artificially created dataset where tree growth is unrelated to the neighbourhood. Both indices detected the competitive neighbourhood effect on tree growth observed in our own dataset but differed in their conclusion regarding neighbour effects in the simulated data. Despite the simulated dataset being generated so there was no relationship between tree growth and their neighbourhood, the FDI detected strong, competitive neighbourhood effects when intrinsic growth was incorrectly related to tree size. In contrast, when we considered the FII as the neighbourhood metric, we correctly did not detect any neighbourhood effects in the simulated data regardless of how size‐dependent growth was described. Synthesis. ‘Competition’ indices are a useful method to characterise the cumulative neighbourhood effect on plant growth; however, we demonstrate that indices which include the size of the focal plant in their calculation can be biased by an inherent relationship between tree growth and initial size. Whilst this bias typically overstates the strength of competition in determining focal tree growth, we show that it can be mitigated by correctly describing intrinsic growth. We discuss the limitations of both index types, provide recommendations for performing statistical modelling and outline how to check for accurate neighbour inference.Keywords
Funding Information
- Holsworth Wildlife Research Endowment
This publication has 45 references indexed in Scilit:
- Complementarity in mixed-species stands of Abies alba and Picea abies varies with climate, site quality and stand densityForest Ecology and Management, 2013
- A drought-induced pervasive increase in tree mortality across Canada's boreal forestsNature Climate Change, 2011
- The contribution of competition to tree mortality in old-growth coniferous forestsForest Ecology and Management, 2011
- Partitioning the Components of Relative Growth Rate: How Important Is Plant Size Variation?The American Naturalist, 2010
- Do position and species identity of neighbours matter in 8–15-year-old post harvest mesic stands in the boreal mixedwood?Forest Ecology and Management, 2010
- Individual-tree diameter growth model for rebollo oak (Quercus pyrenaica Willd.) coppicesForest Ecology and Management, 2008
- FACILITATION BYPINUS FLEXILISDURING SUCCESSION: A HIERARCHY OF MECHANISMS BENEFITS OTHER PLANT SPECIESEcology, 2006
- The effect of competition on individual tree basal area growth in mature stands of Pinus cooperi Blanco in Durango (Mexico)European Journal of Forest Research, 2005
- Models for individual tree mortality in NorwayForest Ecology and Management, 2001
- A model of ponderosa pine growth response to prescribed burningForest Ecology and Management, 1991