Implementation Fidelity of the Transitional Care Model: A Mixed Methods Study
Authors:
- Karen B. HirschmanKHKaren B. Hirschman
- Mark TolesMTMark Toles
- Christina Reilly WhitehouseCWChristina Reilly Whitehouse
- Molly McHughMMMolly McHugh
- Claire ReganCRClaire Regan
- Monica L. AhrensMAMonica L. Ahrens
- Alexandra L. HanlonAHAlexandra L. Hanlon
- Onome H. OsokpoOOOnome H. Osokpo
- Kathleen McCauleyKMKathleen McCauley
- Elizabeth C. ShaidESElizabeth C. Shaid
- Mark V. PaulyMPMark V. Pauly
- Mary D. NaylorMNMary D. Naylor
Open Access
- 9 May 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Global Implementation Research and Applications
- Vol. 6 (3) , 1-16
Abstract
This study, conducted in parallel with the Multisite Replication of the Transitional Care Model, evaluated implementation of the Transitional Care Model protocol delivery (primary aim) and the randomized clinical trial protocol (secondary aim) across nine hospitals and community partners within four healthcare systems. Guided by the Practical, Robust, Implementation, and Sustainability Model and applying a concurrent mixed-methods design, outcomes were assessed using an embedded Reach, Adoption, Implementation, and Maintenance framework, excluding effectiveness. Fidelity to implementation was measured as a standardized count of protocol components delivered as intended (range 0–38). A mean fidelity score of 34 demonstrated that approximately 90% of the minimum dose was delivered, with fidelity improving over time from year 1 (mean 32) to year 3 (mean 35). Qualitative content analysis of 210 meetings identified 24 challenges and 15 strategies related to TCM delivery. Common challenges included engaging patients and caregivers, decreased access to post-acute services, complexity of team-based care, and limited nurse availability. Strategies to address these challenges included testing alternative approaches, building and engaging care networks, targeting patient and caregiver engagement, focusing on care coordination, and emphasizing plans of care. COVID-19 substantially disrupted trial implementation, including the withdrawal of one healthcare system, resulting in reduced enrollment (1004 of 1600 planned patient participants) and staffing delays. At trial completion, one system had integrated the Model into routine practice, while others were planning for sustainability. These findings highlight the importance of ongoing systematic assessment of both intervention delivery and trial implementation to contextualize and interpret outcomes.Keywords
Funding Information
- Arnold Ventures (19-02984)
- Arnold Ventures (19-02984)
- Arnold Ventures (19-02984)
- Arnold Ventures (19-02984)
- Arnold Ventures (19-02984)
- Missouri Foundation for Health (#20-0006-OF-20)
- Missouri Foundation for Health (#20-0006-OF-20)
- Missouri Foundation for Health (#20-0006-OF-20)
- Missouri Foundation for Health (#20-0006-OF-20)
- Missouri Foundation for Health (#20-0006-OF-20)
- Missouri Foundation for Health (#20-0006-OF-20)
- Missouri Foundation for Health (#20-0006-OF-20)
- National Institute of Nursing Research (T32NR009356)
- National Institute of Nursing Research (T32NR009356)
- National Institute of Nursing Research (T32NR009356)
This publication has 37 references indexed in Scilit:
- HF STATS 2024: Heart Failure Epidemiology and Outcomes Statistics An Updated 2024 Report from the Heart Failure Society of AmericaJournal of Cardiac Failure, 2024
- The Application and Evolution of the Practical, Robust Implementation and Sustainability Model (PRISM): History and InnovationsGlobal Implementation Research and Applications, 2024
- Healthcare on the brink: navigating the challenges of an aging society in the United Statesnpj Aging, 2024
- The study protocol to evaluate implementation of the transitional care model in four U.S. healthcare systems during the Covid-19 pandemicArchives of Gerontology and Geriatrics, 2023
- MIRROR-TCM: Multisite Replication of a Randomized Controlled Trial - Transitional Care ModelContemporary Clinical Trials, 2022
- Reports of Forgone Medical Care Among US Adults During the Initial Phase of the COVID-19 PandemicJAMA Network Open, 2021
- The REDCap consortium: Building an international community of software platform partnersJournal of Biomedical Informatics, 2019
- Triangulating perspectives: ontology and epistemology in the analysis of qualitative multiple perspective interviewsInternational Journal of Social Research Methodology, 2019
- Adaptations of the evidence-based Transitional Care Model in the U.S.Social Science & Medicine, 2018
- Comprehensive Discharge Planning and Home Follow-up of Hospitalized EldersJAMA, 1999