Demystifying the Differences between Structure-from-MotionSoftware Packages for Pre-Processing Drone Data
Open Access
Abstract
With the increased availability of low-cost, off-the-shelf drone platforms, drone data become easy to capture and are now a key component of environmental assessments and monitoring. Once the data are collected, there are many structure-from-motion (SfM) photogrammetry software options available to pre-process the data into digital elevation models (DEMs) and orthomosaics for further environmental analysis. However, not all software packages are created equal, nor are their outputs. Here, we evaluated the workflows and output products of four desktop SfM packages (AgiSoft Metashape, Correlator3D, Pix4Dmapper, WebODM), across five input datasets representing various ecosystems. We considered the processing times, output file characteristics, colour representation of orthomosaics, geographic shift, visual artefacts, and digital surface model (DSM) elevation values. No single software package was determined the “winner” across all metrics, but we hope our results help others demystify the differences between the options, allowing users to make an informed decision about which software and parameters to select for their specific application. Our comparisons highlight some of the challenges that may arise when comparing datasets that have been processed using different parameters and different software packages, thus demonstrating a need to provide metadata associated with processing workflows.Keywords
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Accuracy of Digital Surface Models and Orthophotos Derived from Unmanned Aerial Vehicle PhotogrammetryJournal of Surveying Engineering, 2017
- A Statistical Examination of Image Stitching Software Packages For Use With Unmanned Aerial SystemsPhotogrammetric Engineering & Remote Sensing, 2016
- Spatial Accuracy of UAV-Derived Orthoimagery and Topography: Comparing Photogrammetric Models Processed with Direct Geo-Referencing and Ground Control PointsGEOMATICA, 2016
- Evaluation of an unmanned rotorcraft to monitor wintering waterbirds and coastal habitats in British Columbia, CanadaJournal of Unmanned Vehicle Systems, 2015
- Structure from motion photogrammetry in physical geographyProgress in Physical Geography: Earth and Environment, 2015
- Direct Georeferencing of Ultrahigh-Resolution UAV ImageryIEEE Transactions on Geoscience and Remote Sensing, 2013
- Lightweight unmanned aerial vehicles will revolutionize spatial ecologyFrontiers in Ecology and the Environment, 2013
- An Automated Technique for Generating Georectified Mosaics from Ultra-High Resolution Unmanned Aerial Vehicle (UAV) Imagery, Based on Structure from Motion (SfM) Point CloudsRemote Sensing, 2012
- Uncertainties associated with digital elevation models for hydrologic applications: a reviewHydrology and Earth System Sciences, 2007
- Automatic Generation of Remote Sensing Image Mosaics for Mapping Large Natural Hazards Areas2007