Which Classroom Conditions Matter for Mathematics Learning: Bayesian Evidence from PISA 2022, in Colombia
Authors:
Open Access
- 10 September 2026
- journal article
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 15, 1518
Abstract
Understanding which features of classroom instruction are associated with mathematics learning is a central question for education systems worldwide, yet distinguishing instructional associations from differences in family background and prior schooling remains challenging. This study examines the relationship between instructional quality and mathematics achievement using an international assessment framework. Colombian adolescents are among the lowest performers in the OECD mathematics assessment, and substantial variation in achievement occurs across schools, making Colombia a relevant context for examining these relationships. Drawing on PISA 2022, we analyzed 7,367 students nested within 260 schools using a Bayesian two-level model with a random school intercept. Three instructional constructs aligned with the ICALT framework were examined at the school level: classroom orderliness, perceived teacher support, and two facets of cognitive activation. Socioeconomic status, sex, grade of enrolment, and grade repetition were included at the student level. Approximately one-third of the variance in mathematics achievement occurred between schools before predictors were included (ICC = 0.36), declining to approximately one-quarter after their inclusion. Classroom orderliness and reasoning-oriented cognitive activation were positively associated with mathematics achievement, whereas perceived teacher support and thinking-oriented cognitive activation showed negative conditional associations when the other instructional indices were held constant. At the student level, socioeconomic advantage, male sex, higher grade placement, and not having repeated a grade were associated higher achievement. The findings indicate that orderly classroom environments and reasoning-oriented instruction are positively associated with mathematics achievement, while the negative conditional associations highlight the importance of considering overlap among correlated, perception-based instructional measures when interpreting school-level estimates.Keywords
Funding Information
- No funding
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- A decade of PISA: student perceived instructional quality and mathematics achievement across European countriesZDM – Mathematics Education, 2024
- Socioeconomic Status and Student Learning: Insights from an Umbrella ReviewEducational Psychology Review, 2024
- The Association Between Perceived Discriminatory Climate in School and Student Performance in Math and Reading: A Cross-National Analysis Using PISA 2018Journal of Youth and Adolescence, 2022
- Motivational climate in mathematics classrooms: teacher self-efficacy for student engagement, student- and teacher-reported emotional support and student interestZDM – Mathematics Education, 2022
- “Chasing my supervisor all day long like a hungry child seeking her mother!”: Students’ perceptions of supervisory feedbackStudies in Educational Evaluation, 2021
- Instructional quality and achievement inequality: How effective is teaching in closing the social achievement gap?Learning and Instruction, 2019
- Theoretical and methodological challenges in measuring instructional quality in mathematics education using classroom observationsZDM – Mathematics Education, 2016
- Professional competence of teachers: Effects on instructional quality and student development.Journal of Educational Psychology, 2013
- The Role of International Large-Scale Assessments: Perspectives from Technology, Economy, and Educational Research2013
- Assessment of teacher knowledge across countries: a review of the state of researchZDM – Mathematics Education, 2012