The study analyzes cranial metrics of Tlingit and Native American skulls found in California from collection No. 5023 (MAE RAS) transferred to Kunstkamera by Alexander von Middendorff in 1857. Seven Tlingit skulls belong to the Stikine Kwaan people killed during a clan clash in Sitka in March 1852; two skulls of the California Indians were purchased by Middendorff from D. Ward in San Francisco. The objective of the study was to assess the degree of similarity between two American Natives crania and series of ancient and historical groups in the context of the settlement of the Old and New Worlds. The skulls were measured using the standard craniometric program and compared with the populations of the Japanese archipelago, the Russian Far East, and Eastern Siberia. The individual data were subjected to the canonical variate analysis, and a matrix of Mahalanobis D2 distances was calculated. The statistical analyses reveal different biological affinities of two samples under study. The Californian Indians share morphological similarity with the Native people of the Japanese archipelago, which were proved to preserve ancient characteristics of the basal Eurasian Upper Paleolithic populations. This supports the hypothesis based on archaeological data that Indian ancestors had experienced an isolation episode in the Paleo-Sakhalin-Hokkaido-Kuril region before they crossed the Bering Strait. At that, the Tlingit series demonstrates a more specific craniological complex. It was formed after the initial colonization of America and is similar to the ancient Arctic groups.