FromTerra Nulliusto Affirmation: Reconciling Aboriginal Rights with the Canadian Constitution
Author:
- 1 August 2002
- journal article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Canadian Journal of Law and Society / Revue Canadienne Droit et Société
- Vol. 17 (2) , 23-39
Abstract
The Canadian state presents itself as tolerant, anti-colonial and self-critical. Yet, the legal justification for the Crown's acquisition of sovereignty and jurisdiction concerning Indigenous peoples and their lands, relies on the colonial era doctrine of terra nullius which is based on the proposition that Indigenous peoples were sufficiently inferior to enable the Crown to presume that their territories were unoccupied. This paper discusses how the doctrine of terra nullius becomes applied in Canadian law and its limitations as an acceptable proposition at this time in history. It then discusses and evaluates alternatives to that doctrine which have been proposed in various quarters in order to determine the possibilities for the conceptualization and establishment of a political and legal relationship between First Nations and Canada that is post-colonial in its approach and practice. L'État canadien se présente comme tolérant, anti-colonial et auto-critique. Cependant, la justification légale de la Couronne pour acquérir souveraineté et juridiction sur les Peuples autochtones et leurs terres s'appuie sur la doctrine coloniale de la terra nullius qui est fondée sur le postulat que les peuples indigènes étaient inférieurs au point de permettre à la Couronne de présumer que leurs terres étaient inoccupées. L'article analyse comment la doctrine de la terra nullius a fini par s'appliquer en droit canadien et ses limites en tant que proposition acceptable dans la contemporanéité. Dans un second temps, il évalue des alternatives proposées dans des milieux variés pour déterminer si la conceptualisation et la mise en œuvre d'une relation politique et légale entre les Premières nations et le Canada qui serait post-coloniale dans sa perspective et pratique, est possible.Keywords
This publication has 4 references indexed in Scilit:
- Indigenous Difference and the Constitution of Canada2001
- Aboriginal Self-Government and the Construction of Canadian Constitutional IdentityAlberta Law Review, 1992
- Aboriginal Sovereignty and Imperial ClaimsOsgoode Hall Law Journal, 1991
- Aboriginal Rights and Canadian Sovereignty: An Essay on R. v. SparrowAlberta Law Review, 1991