The limitations of shared decision-making in surgery
Authors:
- 3 September 2022
- journal article
- editorial
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in British Journal of Surgery
- Vol. 109 (11) , 1051-1052
Abstract
Shared decision-making (SDM) is a process in which clinicians and patients decide together which treatments to select, based on clinical evidence, clinical advice, and the patient’s informed preferences. The process involves discussion of evidence-based information about options, outcomes, and uncertainties so that the patient is supported in reaching their own decision about their treatment1. This is particularly relevant within surgical practice, when decisions have to be made about treatments which may be irreversible or have potentially temporary or permanent harmful consequences. SDM became a legal requirement in the UK following a Supreme Court ruling on the case of Montgomery versus Lanarkshire Health Board. The General Medical Council, which licenses UK doctors, extended professional standards for informed consent, requiring doctors to take a SDM approach in all significant treatment decisions2. Given this legal requirement, and the central role SDM has in modern patient-centred health care, we cannot advocate against a SDM approach in surgery. However, despite a positive view of SDM among many surgeons, we know from both empirical data and anecdotal discussions that its use in surgical care is highly variable3. The primary reason for inconsistent use of SDM is not reluctance among surgeons, but a product of inadequate data describing risks for complex patients, a reluctance among some patients to engage in the decision, and the nature of gathering evidence to inform major healthcare decisions. Despite our belief in the moral need to offer SDM, we believe there are many everyday situations where this approach is not working.Keywords
This publication has 10 references indexed in Scilit:
- Opportunities for shared decision-making about major surgery: findings from a multi-method qualitative study of decision-making about orthopaedic, colorectal and cardio thoracic surgery with high risk patientsmedRxiv, 2022
- Death after surgery among patients with chronic disease: prospective study of routinely collected data in the English NHSBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2022
- Decision‐making for older patients undergoing emergency laparotomy: defining patient and clinician values and prioritiesColorectal Disease, 2020
- Age of patients undergoing surgeryBritish Journal of Surgery, 2019
- Systematic review of shared decision-making in surgeryBritish Journal of Surgery, 2018
- Montgomery and informed consent: where are we now?BMJ, 2017
- What surgeons tell patients and what patients want to know before major cancer surgery: a qualitative studyBMC Cancer, 2016
- It's Big SurgeryAnnals of Surgery, 2014
- Shared Decision Making — The Pinnacle of Patient-Centered CareNew England Journal of Medicine, 2012
- Determinants of Long-Term Survival After Major Surgery and the Adverse Effect of Postoperative ComplicationsAnnals of Surgery, 2005