Charting a Path for Innovative Toilet Technology Using Multicriteria Decision Analysis
- 8 February 2008
- journal article
- research article
- Published by American Chemical Society (ACS) in Environmental Science & Technology
- Vol. 42 (6) , 1855-1862
Abstract
Practical and theoretically sound methods for analyzing innovative environmental technologies are needed to inform public and private decisions regarding research and development, risk management, and stakeholder communication. By integrating scientific assessments with a characterization of values, multicriteria decision analysis (MCDA) supports the ranking of alternative technology pathways on the basis of technical, financial, and social concerns. We applied MCDA to evaluate the use of NoMix urine separating toilets for managing environmental risk and postponing expensive upgrades to a large wastewater treatment plant near Zürich, Switzerland. Results indicate that, given current priorities, no single, fixed course of action (including the status quo) will be desirable to all stakeholders over the considered time horizon. However, a path forward is suggested that is not significantly disadvantageous to any stakeholder now and leaves open future options, allowing society to achieve overall greater benefits if priorities change, new environmental risks are revealed, or technology improves. While our analysis focuses on a particular catchment in Switzerland, many communities worldwide are faced with an aging and inefficient wastewater treatment infrastructure while also experiencing growth and development. Our framework can help these communities balance the conflicting objectives of diverse stakeholders and gain insight into the role that urine separation can play in transitioning to a more comprehensive and sustainable urban water management system.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Pilot experiments with electrodialysis and ozonation for the production of a fertiliser from urineWater Science & Technology, 2007
- Reducing micropollutants with source control: substance flow analysis of 212 pharmaceuticals in faeces and urineWater Science & Technology, 2007
- Experiences from the implementation of a urine separation system: Goals, planning, realityBuilding and Environment, 2006
- Multicriteria methods for technology foresightJournal of Forecasting, 2003
- Path Dependence, Agency and Technological EvolutionTechnology Analysis & Strategic Management, 2002
- A Framework to Guide Thinking and Analysis Regarding Climate Change PoliciesRisk Analysis, 2001
- Peer Reviewed: Re-engineering the toilet for sustainable wastewater managementEnvironmental Science & Technology, 2001
- Entrapment in large technology systems: institutional commitment and power relationsResearch Policy, 2000
- Life Cycle Assessment of Wastewater Systems: Influence of System Boundaries and Scale on Calculated Environmental LoadsEnvironmental Science & Technology, 1999
- Sprayed to Death: Path Dependence, Lock-in and Pest Control StrategiesThe Economic Journal, 1996