Strategies for Traceability to Prevent Unauthorised GMOs (Including NGTs) in the EU: State of the Art and Possible Alternative Approaches
Authors:
- Jenny TeufelJTJenny Teufel
- Viviana López HernándezVHViviana López Hernández
- Anita GreiterAGAnita Greiter
- Nele KampffmeyerNKNele Kampffmeyer
- Inga HilbertIHInga Hilbert
- Michael EckerstorferMichael Eckerstorfer
- Frank NarendjaFNFrank Narendja
- Andreas HeissenbergerAHAndreas Heissenberger
- Samson SimonSSSamson Simon
Open Access
Abstract
The EU’s regulatory framework for genetically modified organisms (GMOs) was developed for “classical” transgenic GMOs, yet advancements in so-called “new genomic techniques (NGTs)” have led to implementation challenges regarding detection and identification. As traceability can complement detection and identification strategies, improvements to the existing traceability strategy for GMOs are investigated in this study. Our results are based on a comprehensive analysis of existing traceability systems for globally traded agricultural products, with a focus on soy. Alternative traceability strategies in other sectors were also analysed. One focus was on traceability strategies for products with characteristics for which there are no analytical verification methods. Examples include imports of “conflict minerals” into the EU. The so-called EU Conflict Minerals Regulation requires importers of certain raw materials to carry out due diligence in the supply chain. Due diligence regulations, such as the EU’s Conflict Minerals Regulation, can legally oblige companies to take responsibility for certain risks in their supply chains. They can also require the importer to prove the regional origin of imported goods. The insights from those alternative traceability systems are transferred to products that might contain GMOs. When applied to the issue of GMOs, we propose reversing the burden of proof: All companies importing agricultural commodities must endeavour to identify risks of unauthorised GMOs (including NGTs) in their supply chain and, where appropriate, take measures to minimise the risk to raw material imports. The publication concludes that traceability is a means to an end and serves as a prerequisite for due diligence in order to minimise the risk of GMO contamination in supply chains. The exemplary transfer of due diligence to a company in the food industry illustrates the potential benefits of mandatory due diligence, particularly for stakeholders actively managing non-GMO supply chains.Keywords
Funding Information
- German Federal Ministry for the Environment, Nature Conservation, Nuclear Safety and Consumer Protection (BMUV) (3521842200)
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Gains in sustainability using Voluntary Sustainability Standards: A systematic reviewCleaner Logistics and Supply Chain, 2022
- Implications for Agricultural Producers of Using Blockchain for Food Transparency, Study of 4 Food Chains by Cumulative ApproachSustainability, 2021
- Global Regulation of Genetically Modified Crops Amid the Gene Edited Crop Boom – A ReviewFrontiers in Plant Science, 2021
- Genome-Edited Plants: Opportunities and Challenges for an Anticipatory Detection and Identification FrameworkFoods, 2021
- Detection Methods Fit-for-Purpose in Enforcement Control of Genetically Modified Plants Produced with Novel Genomic Techniques (NGTs)Agronomy, 2020
- Plants Developed by New Genetic Modification Techniques—Comparison of Existing Regulatory Frameworks in the EU and Non-EU CountriesFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology, 2019
- Soja não geneticamente modificada no Brasil: a diferenciação interessa ao Produtor?Anais do XI CASI - Congresso de Administração, Sociedade e Inovação, 2018
- Food Traceability and Authenticity2017
- Sustainable Traceability in the Food Supply Chain: The Impact of Consumer Willingness to PaySustainability, 2017
- Business and Human Rights: The Evolving International AgendaAmerican Journal of International Law, 2007